Residential Status of NRIs: Unsettling Settled positions?

Introduction

The residential status of an assessee is extremely important, as it determines the scope of an individual’s taxable income in India. Broadly, a non-resident and a resident but not ordinarily resident (“RNOR”) are not taxed on their foreign income (incomes accruing and arising outside India). However, certain categories of foreign income may still be taxable, such as income received or deemed to be received in India, and in the case of an RNOR, income accruing outside India from a business controlled in, or a profession set up in, India. In contrast, a resident and an ordinarily resident is ordinarily exposed to Indian tax on worldwide income.

Given these consequences, even a small difference in the number of days regarded as spent in India can materially alter the tax treatment of an individual’s overseas income. Additionally, in recent times disclosure schedules in regard to overseas assets and the applicability of the Black Money Act for resident individuals are also an important factor which makes the residential status all the more relevant.

The residence framework has traditionally relied heavily upon objective tests of physical presence prescribed under section 6 of the Income-tax Act, 1961 (“the 1961 Act”)1. Broadly, the framework may be illustrated as follows:

SituationRelevant principle / threshold
General residence testPresence in India for 182 days or more
Alternative general test60 days in the relevant year plus 365 days in the preceding four years
Indian citizen leaving India for overseas employment60-day threshold generally substituted by 182 days
Indian citizen/PIO visiting India60-day threshold substituted by 182 days; reduced to 120 days where total income, other than income from foreign sources, exceeds INR 15 Lacs2
Specified Indian citizen not liable to tax elsewhereDeemed resident where relevant Indian income exceeds INR 15 Lacs; treated as RNOR

The Income-tax Act, 2025 (“the 2025 Act”), applicable from 1 April 2026, substantially retains this architecture, including the basic day-count tests, the overseas-employment and visitor relaxations, the 120-day rule and deemed residency. Importantly, the expression “being outside India, comes on a visit to India” also continues. Thus, the issues considered in recent rulings under the 1961 Act remain relevant under the 2025 Act.

This seemingly straight forward position of residential status has of late been unsettled due to a host of judicial rulings which have dominated the landscape in recent times. An analysis of those rulings is essential to ensure that taxpayers continue to enjoy their non-residential status given the implications of being a resident as explained earlier.

Counting Days in India: Which Days Are to Be Included?

The residential status under Indian income-tax law had come to be settled after a while, as it involved counting the number of days an individual was physically present in India. Various judicial rulings had stressed the physical status of the individual as being relevant for determining the residential status. The only controversy that really remained was whether both the day of arrival and departure of an individual were to be considered in determining the status.

An early ruling of the Authority for Advance Rulings (“AAR”)3 adopted a strict approach in this regard. The AAR held that, for calculating the period of stay in India, both the day on which the individual entered India and the day on which he left India were required to be taken into account. The reasoning was that, even though the individual might have been outside India for part of either day, he was nevertheless physically present in India for some part of that day.

However, in recent times, based on the Karnataka High Court ruling in the case of Manoj Kumar Reddy Nare4 which has been followed by Tribunals across the country, there has been broad agreement that while considering the number of days for determining residential status, only one of the days, i.e., arrival or departure, needs to be considered. This approach is based, inter alia, on the principle contained in section 9 of the General Clauses Act, 18975, that while computing a period “from” a particular date, the first day is to be excluded. Accordingly, the day of arrival is excluded while computing the period of stay in India.

This obviously leads to a beneficial position in cases where there is a photo finish to determine the final residential status.

The residential status under Indian income-tax law had come to be settled after a while, as it involved counting the number of days an individual was physically present in India. Various judicial rulings had stressed the physical status of the individual as being relevant for determining the residential status.

Does the nature of the visa determine the purpose of travel?

Normally the nature of the visa obtained by the individual would not have been very significant in determining the residential status. However, a new angle has been brought in by the Chennai Tribunal’s 2025 decision in the case of M. Mahadevan6 which brings into focus the purpose for which he travels overseas. The taxpayer, popularly known as “Hot Breads Mahadevan”, who had substantial business interests in India and abroad, had claimed non-resident status on the ground that Explanation 1 to section 6(1)1 applied to him, as he had gone outside India for the purposes of business (i.e. employment to be interpreted widely, which included business).

The controversy, amongst other issues which are germane, revolved around the relevance of the nature of the visa in determining the purpose of overseas travel.

The taxpayer admittedly had business interests in jurisdictions including Singapore and Malaysia. The first appellate authority had accepted that his travels to those jurisdictions could be business-related notwithstanding that certain immigration permissions described the journeys as social or visitor travel. The taxpayer had in fact argued that repeated visits to jurisdictions where he had business interests suggested that they were not social or tourist visits but business visits, as no person would tour a place where he had already gone earlier repeatedly. The Tribunal, however, took a stricter view, treating the nature of the visas as relevant evidence and observing that merely having business interests abroad would not establish that every foreign journey was undertaken for business or employment.

The ruling therefore raises an interesting question as to the weight to be attached to the stated purpose of travel under immigration law while determining residential status under income-tax law. While a visa constitutes relevant contemporaneous evidence, the visa category and the activities actually undertaken during a visit need not necessarily be determinative. It is well known that a visa is often determined by the regulations relating to immigration and other considerations, as may be determined by the respective country. One may often note that as far as people arriving in India are concerned, Indian embassies abroad have a differing stance on issuing employment/business/tourist visas, and that is not often necessarily determinative of the reason for travel.

The ruling in Mahadevan nevertheless emphasises that the mere existence of overseas business interests is insufficient to characterise each foreign visit as business-related and the purpose of such travel would need to be supported by the relevant travel documents and contemporaneous evidence of the activities undertaken abroad to make the claim foolproof.

Does the term “Being Outside India” Require Prior Non-Resident Status?

Very recently, a new perspective on the interpretation of the term outside India was adopted by the Bangalore Tribunal’s ruling in Binny Bansal v. DCIT7. The ruling raises an important question concerning the scope of the relaxation available to an Indian citizen or person of Indian origin who, “being outside India, comes on a visit to India”. In the facts of the case, the taxpayer had relocated to Singapore for employment in February 2019 and spent 141 days in India during FY 2019-20, having spent more than 365 days in India during the preceding four years. Consequently, unless the relaxation under Explanation 1(b) to section 6(1)1 applied, he would satisfy the ordinary 60-day/365-day test of residence and be considered as a resident.

The taxpayer contended that the expression “being outside India” refers to the physical situs of the individual and does not require him to have been a non-resident as per Section 61 in an earlier year. Having relocated to Singapore and thereafter travelled to India on visits, he argued that his residential status in an earlier year could not determine whether he was, as a matter of fact, “outside India” when he subsequently came to India on a visit. It was pointed out that the term that was used was “being outside India” as opposed to a “non-resident” which clearly indicated that the person need not be an NRI as per the Income Tax Act. A reference was made to the Circular of the Board8 that explained that the intention of the amendment was to provide an extended threshold to facilitate visits by NRIs and enable them to manage their investments, business interests and other affairs in India without losing their non-resident status.

Unfortunately for the taxpayer, the Tribunal adopted a different interpretation. Referring, inter alia, to the legislative history of Explanation 1(b)1 and CBDT Circular No. 684 of 19948, it considered the relaxation to be intended for persons who were already non-residents and visited India without losing their non-resident status. It therefore denied the benefit to the taxpayer, who had been resident in India in the earlier year.

With the utmost respect to the ruling of the Tribunal, there is considerable force in examining whether “being outside India” should receive a narrow interpretation. The reference to the explanation of section 115C9 in the Circular only provides a reference to a “person of Indian origin” and does not expressly import any additional requirement that the individual should already qualify as a non-resident under the Income-tax Act. Further, if the statutory language does not expressly require the individual to have been a non-resident in an earlier year, reading such a condition into the provision may therefore add a requirement which it does not expressly stipulate. More importantly, if the amendment was intended to enable NRIs residing overseas to participate in the Indian economy and manage their investments and business interests in India, the statutory language should arguably be interpreted in a manner that furthers, rather than unduly restricts, that object. A person who has genuinely moved and is living outside India should not necessarily cease to fall within the expression “being outside India” merely because the day-count rules resulted in his being classified as a resident in an earlier year.

The ruling therefore brings into focus an interpretation of being “outside India” as used in the statute equated to being a “non-resident” as a consequence of the statutory day-count test. Whether the former necessarily imports the latter is an issue which will be argued in higher forums. In any case, the ruling puts in an extra layer of onus on being non-resident in an earlier year which will need to be factored.

Interpretation of tax law always brings in new facets and a new perspective to existing beliefs. The test of residence, though founded on objective day-count rules, may involve important questions of evidence and statutory interpretation.

Residence during Covid-19: Can the Law Compel the Impossible?

The COVID-19 pandemic presented an unprecedented difficulty in the application of residence rules based upon physical presence. International flights were suspended, borders were closed or subject to severe restrictions, and, even as travel gradually resumed, its availability differed depending upon the destination and the arrangements then in force. Consequently, an individual who intended to leave India could, in a given case, remain physically present here not as a matter of choice, but because departure to the country in which he ordinarily resided or was transacting business was simply not possible.

The exceptional nature of such presence raises the question of whether days spent in India because of an inability to leave should necessarily be equated with an ordinary voluntary stay. In that background, taxpayers may note the decision of the Delhi High Court in the case of CIT v. Suresh Nanda,10 which could provide guidance in that regard.

The Delhi High Court’s decision in Suresh Nanda10 provides an important principle in this context. In that case, the taxpayer’s passport had been impounded, as a result of which he was unable to leave India, and his physical presence exceeded the statutory threshold of 182 days. The High Court upheld the exclusion of the period during which the taxpayer was compelled to remain in India, recognising that presence caused by circumstances beyond the individual’s control could not necessarily be treated in the same manner as a voluntary stay. Notably, the impounding of the passport was itself held to be unjustified, illegal and untenable, and this finding was not disputed by the Revenue. Consequently, the taxpayer’s excess stay in India was regarded as a consequence of compulsion rather than choice.

The circumstances created by COVID-19 were, of course, different from the legal restraint involved in Suresh Nanda. However, the underlying principle assumes relevance: where an individual has the intention to leave India but is prevented from doing so by circumstances which make departure impossible, continued physical presence may not necessarily reflect a voluntary choice to remain in India.

The CBDT itself recognised this difficulty and, through Circular No. 11/202011, provided specified relief in computing the period of stay in India for FY 2019-20 for individuals who had come to India on a visit and were unable to leave owing to quarantine, lockdown and the suspension of international flights. While the circular provided some relief, it has a lot of preconditions which are required to be met.

Over and above the relief provided by the Circular, there is a more fundamental principle involved: The maxim is “LEX NON COGIT AD IMPOSSIBILIA” (Broom’s Legal Maxims - P.162) - the law does not compel a man to do that which he cannot possibly perform. This principle has been recognised by the Supreme Court in Raj Kumar Dey v. Tarapada Dey12 and, more recently, in Engineering Analysis Centre of Excellence (P.) Ltd.13. If an individual could not leave India because no practicable means of travelling to his country of residence was available, the law ought not ordinarily to proceed on the premise that he could nevertheless have departed merely because the statutory residence test is expressed by reference to physical presence.

Conclusion

To conclude, it is important to keep a note of the rulings discussed above to ensure that there is no slip between the cup and the lip. Interpretation of tax law always brings in new facets and a new perspective to existing beliefs. The test of residence, though founded on objective day-count rules, may involve important questions of evidence and statutory interpretation. They also underscore the need to maintain reliable travel records, adequately substantiate the purpose of overseas travel and carefully consider the implications of visits to India. As the old maxim goes, “A stitch in time saves nine”. Similarly, one will need to keep in mind emerging rulings to ensure that planning for residence does not require too much of stitching or discovering new arguments at the time of the assessment.

References

  • Income-tax Act, 1961
  • Income-tax Act, 2025
  • General Clauses Act, 1897
  • Black Money (Undisclosed Foreign Income and Assets) and Imposition of Tax Act, 2015
  • CBDT Circular No. 684 dated 10 June 1994
  • CBDT Circular No. 11 of 2020 dated 8 May 2020, F. No. 370142/18/2020-TPL
  • In re, Petition No. 7 of 1995, [1997] 223 ITR 462 (AAR)
  • Director of Income-tax (International Taxation) v. Manoj Kumar Reddy Nare, [2011] 245 CTR 350 (Karnataka)
  • DCIT v. M. Mahadevan, [2025] 175 taxmann.com 383 (Chennai - Trib.)
  • Binny Bansal v. DCIT, [2026] 182 taxmann.com 226 (Bangalore - Trib.)
  • CIT v. Suresh Nanda, [2015] 375 ITR 172 (Delhi)
  • Raj Kumar Dey v. Tarapada Dey, (1987) 4 SCC 398 (SC)
  • Engineering Analysis Centre of Excellence (P.) Ltd. v. CIT, [2021] 432 ITR 471 (SC)
  • Broom’s Legal Maxims
Authors may be reached at eboard@icai.in
  1. Section 6(1) of the 1961 Act provides that an individual is said to be resident in India in any previous year, if he –
(a) is in India in that year for a period or periods amounting in all to 182 days or more; or
(c) having within the four years preceding that year been in India for a period or periods amounting in all to 365 days or more, is in India for a period or periods amounting in all to 60 days or more in that year.
  1. Explanation 1 thereto, inter alia, substitutes the 60-day period with 182 days in the case of –
(a) an Indian citizen leaving India as a member of the crew of an Indian ship or for the purposes of employment outside India
(b) an Indian citizen/PIO who, “being outside India, comes on a visit to India”, with the 60-day period being substituted with 120 days where such individual’s total income, other than income from foreign sources, exceeds INR 15 lakh during the relevant previous year.
  1. Section 6(1A) provides for deemed residence of an Indian citizen having total income, other than income from foreign sources, exceeding INR 15 lakh, where he is not liable to tax in any other country or territory by reason of domicile, residence or other similar criteria. ↩
  2. Explanation 1 to Section 6(6) of the 1961 Act provides that for the purposes of this section, “income from foreign sources” means the income, which accrues or arises outside India (except income derived from a business controlled in or a profession set up in India) and which is not deemed to accrue or arise in India. ↩
  3. In re [1997] 223 ITR 462 (AAR) ↩
  4. Director of Income-tax (International Taxation) v. Manoj Kumar Reddy Nare [2011] 245 CTR 350 (Karnataka) ↩
  5. Section 9(1) of the General Clauses Act, 1897: In any Central Act or Regulation made after the commencement of this Act, it shall be sufficient, for the purpose of excluding the first in a series of days or any other period of time, to use the word ‘from’, and, for the purpose of including the last in a series of days or any other period of time, to use the word ‘to’. ↩
  6. DCIT v. M. Mahadevan [2025] 175 taxmann.com 383 (Chennai - Trib.) ↩
  7. Binny Bansal v. DCIT [2026] 182 taxmann.com 226 (Bangalore - Trib.) ↩
  8. CBDT Circular No. 684 dated 10 June 1994, paras 19 - 19.3 ↩
  9. Section 115C(e) of the 1961 Act provides that “non-resident Indian” means an individual, being a citizen of India or a person of Indian origin who is not a “resident”. The Explanation thereto provides that a person shall be deemed to be of Indian origin if he, or either of his parents or any of his grandparents, was born in undivided India. ↩
  10. CIT v. Suresh Nanda [2015] 375 ITR 172 (Delhi) ↩
  11. CBDT Circular No. 11 of 2020 dated 8 May 2020, F. No. 370142/18/2020-TPL ↩
  12. Raj Kumar Dey v. Tarapada Dey (1987) 4 SCC 398 (SC) ↩
  13. Engineering Analysis Centre of Excellence (P.) Ltd. v. CIT [2021] 432 ITR 471 (SC) ↩