A. FACTS OF THE CASE
1. A Company acquired a plot under a 90-year lease deed executed with the New Okhla Industrial Development Authority (NOIDA Authority).
2. The Company expects the lease to be renewed upon expiry, in line with prevailing practices of the Authority.
3. The plot is retained for the Company's own office and business purposes, with no intention of sale or transfer.
Important Clauses in Lease Deed and Contextual Note provided by the Querist
1. Clause 4 - In addition to the premium of plot, lease rent @ 2.5% of the premium per annum shall be payable in advance. Apart from premium, the Company made a One Time Lease Rent payment, which covered the entire lease rent obligation in advance.
2. Clause 8 - The Lessee shall complete the building within five years from the date of allotment or four years from the date of possession, whichever is less. No further extension shall be allowed. However, the land remained vacant and not built upon within the stipulated period, and therefore the Company had to pay extension charges multiple times.
3. Clause 14 - The Lessee may, with previous permission, mortgage the Demised Premises for raising loans. In the event of foreclosure, the Lessor shall be entitled to recover such percentage as decided by it of the unearned increase in the value of the Demised Premises, and shall have the pre-emptive right to purchase the mortgaged property. The Company has never mortgaged the land and has no intention of mortgaging or exiting the property.
4. Clauses 18 and 19 - The Lessee will not assign, relinquish, sublet, transfer etc. without previous permission of the Lessor. Every transfer, assignment, relinquishment, mortgage or subletting shall be subject to the transferee being bound by all covenants and conditions and answerable to the Lessor. The Company has never attempted to exit, assign or transfer the demised premises.
C&AG's Observation during Supplementary Audit
The Company has not recognised the Right-of-Use (ROU) asset and lease liability as per Ind AS 116. Instead, it has shown the leasehold land under 'Property, Plant and Equipment' and is charging depreciation on it. Thus, the accounting treatment of leased assets was not in compliance with Ind AS 116.
B. QUERY
Whether provisions of Ind AS 116 as to creation of Right-of-Use Assets will be applicable on the above land.
C. POINTS CONSIDERED BY THE COMMITTEE
1. In-substance purchase vs right of use
(a) In long-term leases, it must be examined whether the arrangement represents an in-substance purchase, i.e., transfers control of the underlying asset (irrespective of legal title), or only the right to control the use of the asset.
(b) If the transferee obtains control of the asset, it should be accounted for as per Ind AS 16, 'Property, Plant and Equipment'.
2. Meaning of control
(a) As per Ind AS 115, control of an asset refers to the ability to direct the use of, and obtain substantially all of the remaining benefits from, the asset.
(b) As per the Conceptual Framework, an entity controls an economic resource if it has the present ability to direct its use and obtain the economic benefits from it. This includes the right to deploy the resource in its own activities or allow another party to deploy it.
3. Rights of the Company under the lease deed
(a) The Company has been granted the right to use the demised premises for 90 years for construction of building or other facilities, upon payment of premium and annual lease rent.
(b) It may assign, relinquish, sublet, transfer or sub-divide the land and building with prior permission of the Lessor.
(c) Therefore, the Company has the present ability to direct the use of the land for the period of 90 years.
4. Restrictions under the lease deed
(a) The right to transfer, assign, sublet etc. is subject to prior permission of the lessor and such terms and conditions as the lessor may determine.
(b) Mortgage is permitted only with prior permission. On foreclosure, the lessor is entitled to a share in the unearned increase in value of the land and has a pre-emptive right to purchase the property.
(c) The land must be used only for the specified purpose and in accordance with the plans, building regulations and directions of the lessor. Non-compliance may result in cancellation of the lease and resumption of possession.
5. Whether the Company controls the land
(a) Due to these conditions, it cannot be said that all remaining or future economic benefits from the land will flow to the Company. The Company merely has the right to significant economic benefits from the use of the asset, and not from the asset itself (which includes the right to sell etc.).
(b) The Company is not exposed to significant risks and rewards of ownership. Hence, the land cannot be considered to be controlled by the Company.
(c) Accounting is based on current rights and obligations under the contract and not on general practices. Usage or intended usage of an asset does not determine control.
(d) The manner or timing of payment of lease rent does not change the nature of the arrangement.
(e) Payment of extension charges indicates continuation of the lease and shows that the Company does not exercise absolute control over the use (or non-use) of the asset.
(f) The conditional ability to mortgage cannot be considered as ownership over the land.
(g) The land is leasehold, and there is no evidence that it will be converted into freehold. Even if it is converted in future, at present there is no control. Hence, the land cannot be recognised as PPE under Ind AS 16.
6. Whether the arrangement is a lease under Ind AS 116
(a) A contract contains a lease if it conveys the right to control the use of an identified asset for a period of time in exchange for consideration.
(b) The identified asset is a specific plot of land.
(c) The lease is for a defined period of 90 years, satisfying the requirement of 'a period of time'.
(d) Consideration has been paid in the form of upfront premium and stipulated lease rentals.
(e) The Company can construct and use the land for its purposes as per approved plans and conditions, obtain economic benefits from its use, and direct how it is used, subject to the lease deed.
(f) The arrangement does not transfer ownership of the land; it grants a right to use the asset for a period of time.
(g) The lease deed contains clauses on lease rent, cancellation, reversion etc., which are consistent with a lease rather than a sale.
D. OPINION OF THE COMMITTEE
The contract conveys the right to control the use of an identified asset (land) for a specified period in exchange for consideration. Therefore, the arrangement is in the nature of a lease within the scope of Ind AS 116, 'Leases', and the land cannot be recognised as Property, Plant and Equipment under Ind AS 16.