Legal Decision Updates

November 2026

Archived Legal Decision Updates Download PDF
01.

LD/75/33 ITAT Delhi: ITA No. 6559/Del/2025 Welspun Aunta Simaria Project Pvt. Ltd Vs. The Dy. Commissioner of Income Tax 06th October 2026

ITAT held that interest paid by the Assessee to NHAI on mobilization advances is not liable for deduction of tax at source u/s 194A; Payment made to corporation established under a statutory enactment falling within the ambit of Notification No. 3489 dated 22.10.1970 is outside the purview of the TDS obligation under section 194A; Reliance placed on Allahabad HC judgment in Canara Bank.
02.

LD/75/34 Bombay High Court: Writ Petition No. 4002 of 2026 Farah Khurshed Titina Vs. The Income Tax Officer 05th October 2026

Bombay HC quashed the impugned order rejecting assessee’s application u/s 270AA seeking waiver of penalty and immunity from initiation of proceedings u/s 276C or Section 276CC; Assessee, realising her mistake in making erroneous claims under Chapter VIA, had filed a revised computation of income and voluntarily paid tax and interest and Revenue had initiated penalty u/s 270A for misreporting; In the wake of amendment to Section 270AA vide Finance Act, 2026, by which an application for waiver of penalty could be made even in cases of misreporting of income, assessee had filed a second application seeking waiver of the said penalty, which also was rejected.
03.

LD/75/35 ITAT Ahmedabad: I.T.A. No. 2123/ Ahd/2025 Shweta Manish Jain Vs. The Income Tax Officer 01st October 2026

ITAT remitted matter back to AO noting that the assessment record did not indicate any independent inquiry or verification by the Assessing Officer with regard to the specific transactions undertaken by the assessee with M/s Niyati Traders; Burden lied on Revenue to demonstrate that transaction recorded as sale was not a sale transaction or amount received from Niyati Traders represented something other than sale consideration; However, ITAT remarked that where purchaser specifically admits that transactions were accommodation entries, it is supported by independent corroborative material, mere recording of receipts as sales and offering resultant profit to tax would not establish genuineness of underlying transactions.
04.

LD/75/36 Bombay High Court: Income Tax Appeal No. 2642 of 2018 The Prin. Commissioner of Income Tax Vs. Ashoka Buildcon P Ltd. 01st October 2026

High Court dismissed Revenue’s appeal against ITAT order deleting penalty u/s 271(1)(c); Objection to ITAT finding cannot be a substitute for a substantial question of law; Section 260A does not confer general appellate jurisdiction permitting routine reconsideration of evidence or substitution of High Court opinion for factual findings of lower authorities; Revenue merely dressed up objections to ITAT order as substantial question of law.
05.

LD/75/37 Bombay High Court: Writ Petition No. 3233 of 2019 H. P. Diamonds India Pvt. Ltd. Vs. The Deputy Commissioner of Income Tax 30th September 2026

Bombay HC sets aside notice u/s 143(2) noting that since issuance of notice u/s 143(2) is the starting point of assessment proceedings, the AO cannot issue notice u/s 143(2), or even notice u/s 142(1), before disposing of objections filed by the assessee by a speaking order; Analysis of Sections 148, 143 and 142 makes it clear that notice u/s 143(2) is issued only when a return is filed in response to notice u/s 148 and issuance of such notice marks the starting point of assessment proceedings.
06.

LD/75/38 ITAT Delhi: ITA No. 4637/Del/2025 Alsorg Interiors India Pvt. Ltd. Vs. The Deputy Commissioner of Income Tax 24th September 2026

ITAT deleted addition towards unaccounted sale by applying ad-hoc profit rate @ 8.5% noting that jurisdictional condition prescribed u/s 149(1)(b) remained unfulfilled; Reasons recorded did not identify the exact factual legal limb of sec 149(1)(b) which was sought to be invoked; As per ITAT, alleged unaccounted business receipts/payments/ expenses could not be classified as ‘asset’, within the meaning of Section 149(1)(b) so as to justify re-opening after expiry of 3 years; ITAT remarked that profit estimation could have been sustained when the Revenue first established actual unaccounted sales or receipts attributable to AY 2016-17 to 2022-23, which itself failed.
07.

LD/75/39 Madras High Court: Rev.Appl. No. 107 of 2021 V. Babu. Vs. The Deputy Commissioner of Income Tax 28th September 2026

Madras HC dismissed the Assessee’s Review Petition against judgment upholding the addition u/s 68; HC noted that initial burden u/s 68 rested on assessee and that a paper arrangement or routing of funds through a personal account did not discharge that burden, and the Assessee’s explanation has already been rejected by ITAT; Reconsideration of existing factual explanations as new material would amount to rehearing an appeal, which review jurisdiction prohibits; HC held that unsupported accommodation entry explanation cannot justify restricting taxation to the commission allegedly retained by the assessee.
08.

LD/75/40 ITAT Delhi: ITA No 2537/Del/2026 Subhash Chand Gulati Vs. The Income Tax Officer 25th September 2026

ITAT held that GST refund did not constitute taxable income if the underlying tax payment was not claimed as a deduction; ITAT rejected adjustment under Section 143(1) solely based on disclosure made in Form 3CD; Reliance placed on coordinate bench ruling in Ecoenergy Insights to note that reporting a GST refund in the tax audit report did not make it taxable where the underlying payment had not been claimed as expenditure in the relevant or any preceding AY.
09.

LD/75/41 ITAT Varanasi: ITA No. 49/VNS/2018 The Asst. Commissioner of Income Tax Vs. Shri Bajrang Bahadur Singh Marhatha 24th September 2026

ITAT upheld 6% profit estimation u/s 145(3) holding that mandatory disallowance under Section 40A(3) requires specific identification and verification of cash payments exceeding the prescribed limit to a person per day; ITAT noted that AO was required to identify and verify each cash payment exceeding Rs. 20,000 to a single person on a single day; ITAT further held that Assessee’s explanations regarding purchases from truck drivers and labour payments through site incharges required examination, including with reference to Rule 6DD(j)/(k).
10.

LD/75/42 ITAT Mumbai: ITA No. 26/Mum/2026 Rudaram D. Choudhary Vs. The Income Tax Officer 15th September 2026

ITAT deleted penalty levied u/s 271(1)(c) on account of income disclosed in the return of income filed in response to Section 148 notice, observing that since the AO accepted the income so disclosed by the Assessee with no variation/additions, no penalty for concealment of particulars of income, can survive; ITAT noted that the AO had accepted the quantum and nature of gross receipts so offered by the Assessee as arising out of his business; In absence of any particulars of income being concealed given that there is no variation between the returned income and assessed income, the computational machinery also failed.
11.

LD/75/43 ITAT Mumbai: I.T.A. No. 3473/ Mum/2025 Godrej Consumer Products Limited Vs. The Dy. Commissioner of Income Tax 15th September 2026

ITAT quashed order passed u/s 201 as invalid for non-mentioning of Document Identification Number (DIN); Order passed u/s 201(1)/(1A) cannot be treated as an “assessment order” for the purposes of Section 292B (which validates certain orders) merely because such proceedings have been judicially described as being “akin to an assessment” in a different context; Absence of DIN cannot be brushed aside as a mere technical or hyper-technical defect.