World has transformed into an expansive marketplace where borders exist primarily on maps, while ideas, merchandise, capital, and prospects flow across nations with extraordinary ease. This seamless economic integration gains momentum through technology and digital innovation, allowing software, financial instruments, data and intangible assets to traverse jurisdictions instantly via worldwide communication systems.
Whether ‘Guidelines on Ethical Issues, 2026’
replaces the ‘Council General Guidelines,
2008’?
Yes, the “Guidelines on Ethical Issues, 2026”
replaces the “Council General Guidelines, 2008
[Council Guidelines No.1- CA(7)/02/2008]”. The
“Guidelines on Ethical Issues, 2026” have been
issued under Section 15(2)(fa) of...Yes, the “Guidelines on Ethical Issues, 2026”
replaces the “Council General Guidelines, 2008
[Council Guidelines No.1- CA(7)/02/2008]”. The
“Guidelines on Ethical Issues, 2026” have been
issued under Section 15(2)(fa) of the Chartered
Accountants Act, 1949.
Read More
Whether a member of the Institute who is an
employee will be held guilty of professional
misconduct despite not being in practice if he
does not exercise due diligence in the conduct
of his duties?
Yes, Chapter II of “Guidelines on Ethical Issues,
2026” specifies that a member of the Institute
who is an employee shall be deemed to be guilty
of professional misconduct if...Yes, Chapter II of “Guidelines on Ethical Issues,
2026” specifies that a member of the Institute
who is an employee shall be deemed to be guilty
of professional misconduct if he does not exercise
due diligence and being grossly negligent in the
conduct of his duties.
Read More
Whether a member of the Institute in practice
is required to maintain books of accounts?
Yes, Chapter III of the guidelines specifies that a
member of the Institute in practice or the firm of
Chartered Accountants of which he is a partner,
shall maintain and...Yes, Chapter III of the guidelines specifies that a
member of the Institute in practice or the firm of
Chartered Accountants of which he is a partner,
shall maintain and keep in respect of his/its
professional practice, proper books of account in
electronic or physical form.
Read More
Ep. 549 — Transfer Pricing & International Tax for Indian GCCs: From Cost Centre to Value Creator
CA Journal
00:00--:--
Transfer Pricing & International Tax for Indian GCCs: From Cost Centre to Value CreatorIndia’s Global Capability Centre (GCC) ecosystem has moved well beyond the traditional captive back-office model. Many GCCs now undertake product development, engineering, analytics, cybersecurity, artificial intelligence, research and global decision-support functions. This evolution has direct transfer pricing and international tax consequences. A cost-plus model cannot be treated as a permanent characterisation merely because an Indian entity is captive. The appropriate tax outcome must follow the actual functions performed, assets employed, risks controlled and value created in India. The 2026 safe harbour reforms, multi-year ALP determination framework and the APA framework provide useful certainty mechanisms, but their suitability depends on the underlying operating model.India’s GCC story has changedThe scale of India’s GCC ecosystem is now significant. The Economic Survey 2025-26 records approximately 1,700 GCCs in FY24, employing about 19 lakh professionals and generating an estimated revenue of USD 64.6 billion. More importantly, the Survey notes that GCCs have evolved from support-orientated functions into integral components of multinational groups, undertaking product development, engineering, analytics, cybersecurity and AI-enabled digital functions.1That evolution creates a basic tax question. Can a centre that was historically characterised as a routine captive service provider continue to be priced in the same manner after it begins to employ product architects, lead global transformation programmes, influence product roadmaps, manage important risks or contribute materially to intellectual property?For transfer pricing purposes, “GCC” is a business description, not a tax characterisation. The Indian analysis must still begin with the arm’s length principle and the actual controlled transactions. Section 165 of the Income-tax Act, 2025, read with Rules 79 and 80 of the Income-tax Rules, 2026, requires the arm’s length price to be determined using the most appropriate method, having regard, among other factors, to the nature of the transaction and the functions performed by the associated enterprises.2 The OECD Transfer Pricing Guidelines similarly require accurate delineation of the transaction based on economically relevant characteristics, including functions, assets and risks, with particular attention to the conduct of the parties and control over economically significant risks.3Characterisation must precede benchmarkingA recurring practical problem is to start with the desired pricing result and then draft the functional analysis around it. For a GCC, the order should be reversed. The operating model should first be understood, then the transaction characterised, and only thereafter should the pricing method and comparable set be selected.A useful way to view GCCs is as a continuum as depicted in Table 1 below.Table 1: Viewing GCCs as a continuumGCC operating profileIndicative characteristicsPrimary tax focusRoutine support centreExecutes defined processes under group direction; does not control economically significant risks or make unique contributions to valuable intangibles.A cost-based return under TNMM or another appropriate method may be supportable, subject to proper comparability analysis.Specialist or knowledge centreUndertakes analytics, finance, cybersecurity, data science, regulatory support or other judgement-intensive functions.Generic low-end ITeS comparable may not reflect employee profile, complexity or value contribution.Contract R&D or product engineering centrePerforms development activity and may influence technical outcomes, while funding, strategic direction and risk control may remain overseas.Analyse who conceptualises the product, controls development risk, makes go/no-go decisions and owns or economically contributes to resulting intangibles.Strategic or innovation hubSenior India personnel may lead global products, platforms, functions or transformation programmes.Where India and overseas entities make unique and valuable contributions or jointly control important risks, a routine tested-party approach should be re-examined.Indian jurisprudence supports this emphasis on functional substance. In Rampgreen Solutions Pvt. Ltd. v. CIT, the Delhi High Court rejected a broad approach that treated all ITeS providers as comparable, recognising the importance of differences between lower-end BPO functions and higher-end KPO activities.4 The principle is directly relevant to GCC benchmarking: industry labels cannot substitute for a detailed functional comparison.Cost-plus is an outcome, not a permanent entitlementThere is nothing inherently inappropriate about cost-plus remuneration for a captive GCC. It can be an arm’s length outcome where the Indian entity performs routine or limited-risk functions, and the foreign principal genuinely performs and controls the economically significant entrepreneurial functions. The risk arises when a model designed for yesterday’s functions is carried forward after the business has changed.Three areas merit particular attention.First, risk control. Contractual allocation alone is insufficient where conduct points elsewhere. The current safe harbour rules themselves reflect this principle. For eligible information technology services, an Indian service provider must operate with “insignificant risk”. The Rules look to whether the foreign principal performs the economically significant and critical functions, provides capital and significant assets, actually supervises and controls the activities, and retains legal and economic ownership of relevant intangibles. If the contract says that the foreign principal controls a risk, but the conduct shows that the Indian entity does so, the contractual terms are not the final determinant.5Second, intangibles. A GCC need not legally own an intellectual property right to make economically significant contributions to it. For development and technology-intensive GCCs, the analysis should identify who performs and controls the development, enhancement, maintenance, protection and exploitation functions, who bears the relevant risks, and whether the Indian entity possesses unique know-how, systems, workforce capability or other valuable contributions. The objective is not to assign residual profit to India merely because skilled employees are located here. It is to ensure that the remuneration reflects the functions actually performed and risks actually controlled.For development and technology-intensive GCCs, the analysis should identify who performs and controls the development, enhancement, maintenance, protection and exploitation functions, who bears the relevant risks, and whether the Indian entity possesses unique know-how, systems, workforce capability or other valuable contributions.Third, business restructuring. Section 163 expressly includes a business restructuring or reorganisation with an associated enterprise within the definition of an international transaction, irrespective of whether it has an immediate or future bearing on profit, income, losses or assets.6 Therefore, when a GCC moves from execution to ownership of functions, when decision rights or risks are transferred to India, or when valuable teams, know-how, contractual rights or business opportunities are relocated, the issue may be wider than a change in markup. The group should consider whether a restructuring transaction has occurred and whether independent parties would have required compensation.The 2026 certainty tools: safe harbour, multi-year ALP determination and APAThe Income-tax Rules, 2026, have made the safe harbour regime more relevant to GCCs. “Information technology services” now cover software development services, IT-enabled services, KPO services and software-related contract R&D. For an eligible transaction, the safe harbour requires an operating profit margin of at least 15.5 per cent on operating expenses where aggregate operating revenue does not exceed INR 2,000 crore.7For qualifying IT services, a valid safe harbour option continues for five consecutive tax years, with the INR 2,000 crore threshold tested for the first year.8 This can materially reduce annual pricing uncertainty for a stable limited-risk model. However, it should not be viewed simply as a margin election. The eligibility conditions require the underlying functions and risk profile to fit the safe harbour framework. Transfer pricing documentation and reporting obligations also continue notwithstanding the election.9There is also a strategic trade-off. Rule 93 provides that where the transfer price is accepted under the safe harbour provisions, the taxpayer cannot invoke the mutual agreement procedure under the applicable tax treaty for that transaction.10 Groups with material bilateral double taxation exposure should therefore compare the certainty offered by safe harbour with the protection available through a bilateral APA.The APA programme has become increasingly significant. CBDT entered into 219 APAs in FY2025-26, including 84 bilateral APAs, taking the cumulative number to 1,034.11 For a large GCC with recurring transactions, a stable operating model and significant potential controversy, an APA can address method selection, mark-up, cost base, segmentation, critical assumptions and, in a bilateral case, double taxation risk over multiple years.The Rules also contain a specific procedural framework for unilateral APAs where the primary covered transaction is eligible IT services. If such an agreement is not entered into within two years from the end of the quarter in which the application is made, the proceedings are treated as closed, subject to a taxpayer-requested extension of six months.12 This should be described as a procedural time limit rather than a guarantee that an APA will necessarily be concluded within two years.A separate 2026 reform permits an option for determination of arm’s length price for two succeeding tax years in the same transfer pricing proceeding. The mechanism applies only where the relevant transactions remain similar, including material consistency in functions, assets and risks, no change in the pricing method and no material change in contractual allocation of responsibilities, risks and benefits.13 This is especially relevant to GCCs because it creates a useful dividing line: a stable service model may benefit from multi-year certainty, while a GCC undergoing genuine functional transformation may not satisfy the required consistency.The international tax perimeter cannot be separated from TPAs GCCs become more integrated with global operations, the analysis should not stop at the Indian entity’s margin.Permanent establishment is one such area. The existence of an Indian subsidiary or the outsourcing of work to India does not, by itself, create a fixed place for PE of the foreign enterprise. In E-Funds IT Solution Inc., the Supreme Court emphasised that the foreign enterprise must have a fixed place in India at its disposal through which it carries on its own business.14 However, the PE analysis remains treaty-specific and fact-dependent. The role of foreign personnel, authority exercised by India-based personnel, contract negotiation, customer interaction, secondments and the actual use of premises can all become relevant under the applicable DTAA, as modified where relevant by the Multilateral Instrument.Transfer pricing and PE attribution also intersect. In Morgan Stanley, the Supreme Court recognised that where an Indian associated enterprise constituting the relevant PE has been remunerated at arm’s length and the transfer pricing analysis fully captures the functions performed and risks assumed, no further profit may remain for attribution. Conversely, where the analysis does not adequately capture those functions and risks, further attribution may be required.15 For a GCC, this makes the quality of the FAR analysis important beyond the Indian entity’s transfer pricing assessment.Place of effective management, or POEM, is another emerging governance issue where senior global roles migrate to India. Under section 6(10) of the Income-tax Act, 2025, a foreign company may be resident in India if its place of effective management is in India, meaning the place where key management and commercial decisions necessary for the business as a whole are, in substance, made.16 CBDT’s POEM guidance requires a fact-based enquiry into who actually makes such decisions and where they are made, with substance prevailing over form.17 The presence of senior executives in an Indian GCC does not automatically establish POEM. The relevant question is whether they are making business-wide key management decisions for the foreign company rather than merely managing Indian operations or implementing global policy.Cross-border payments should also be reviewed separately from the service-provider margin. Royalty, software, technical service, management fee, cost allocation and secondment arrangements may raise withholding and treaty-characterisation questions. The answer may differ materially depending on the wording of the relevant DTAA, including whether a fees-for-technical-services or fees-for-included-services article contains a “make available” condition. A GCC tax framework should therefore link transfer pricing, withholding tax and treaty analysis rather than treat them as independent compliance streams.What should GCC tax governance look like?For a mature GCC, the annual transfer pricing study should be the output of the governance process, not the first time the group examines its functional profile.A practical framework should include an annual review of decision rights and risk control; mapping of global and India-based senior roles; identification of changes in product ownership, IP-related functions and customer-facing activity; transaction-level and segmental financial data; intercompany agreements aligned with actual conduct; evidence supporting the foreign principal’s control of important risks where a limited-risk model is adopted; and contemporaneous documentation of significant restructurings.The group should also establish trigger events for a deeper review. Examples include appointment of a global product or functional head in India, transfer of R&D leadership, commencement of direct customer negotiations, migration of IP-related decision-making, assumption of material market or development risk, major acquisitions or reorganisations, or a significant change in the GCC’s employee and cost profile.A GCC can remain a limited-risk service provider even while becoming larger and more sophisticated, provided the facts support that characterisation.The central point is straightforward. A GCC can remain a limited-risk service provider even while becoming larger and more sophisticated, provided the facts support that characterisation. Equally, growth in strategic decision-making, control of risk or unique contributions may require a different pricing analysis. Neither outcome should be presumed.Closing PerspectiveIndia’s GCC growth is creating a new generation of transfer pricing and international tax questions. The challenge is no longer merely to benchmark a markup at year-end. The more important task is to ensure that the legal agreements, transfer pricing characterisation, risk allocation, IP framework and international tax position continue to reflect how the business is actually operated.For tax leaders and advisers, the right starting question is therefore not “What margin should the GCC earn?” but “What has the GCC become, and does the tax model still match it?”◆◆◆Author may be reached at eboard@icai.inGovernment of India, Ministry of Finance, Economic Survey 2025-26, para 7.34 and Chart VII.12, ‘Growth of GCCs Ecosystem’.Income-tax Act, 2025, section 165; Income-tax Rules, 2026, rules 79 and 80.OECD, OECD Transfer Pricing Guidelines for Multinational Enterprises and Tax Administrations 2022, particularly Chapters I and VI.Rampgreen Solutions Pvt. Ltd. v. CIT (2015) 377 ITR 533 (Delhi).Income-tax Rules, 2026, rule 87(1)(a) and rule 87(2).Income-tax Act, 2025, section 163(1)(e).Income-tax Rules, 2026, rules 88 and 89(2), Table, Sl. No. 1.Income-tax Rules, 2026, rule 91(1) and (2).Income-tax Rules, 2026, rule 89(6), read with sections 171 and 172 of the Income-tax Act, 2025.Income-tax Rules, 2026, rule 93.Press Information Bureau, Ministry of Finance, ‘CBDT signs record 219 Advance Pricing Agreements (APAs) in FY 2025-26’, 31 March 2026.Income-tax Rules, 2026, rule 109(13) and (14).Income-tax Rules, 2026, rule 82, particularly rule 82(5).Assistant Director of Income-tax v. E-Funds IT Solution Inc. (2017) 399 ITR 34 (SC).DIT (International Taxation) v. Morgan Stanley & Co. Inc. (2007) 292 ITR 416 (SC).Income-tax Act, 2025, section 6(10).CBDT Circular No. 6 of 2017 dated 24 January 2017, Guiding Principles for determination of Place of Effective Management (POEM).The Chartered Accountant | www.icai.org | November 2026 | pp. 604–607
Ep. 550 — Residential Status of NRIs: Unsettling Settled positions
CA Journal
00:00--:--
Residential Status of NRIs: Unsettling Settled positions?IntroductionThe residential status of an assessee is extremely important, as it determines the scope of an individual’s taxable income in India. Broadly, a non-resident and a resident but not ordinarily resident (“RNOR”) are not taxed on their foreign income (incomes accruing and arising outside India). However, certain categories of foreign income may still be taxable, such as income received or deemed to be received in India, and in the case of an RNOR, income accruing outside India from a business controlled in, or a profession set up in, India. In contrast, a resident and an ordinarily resident is ordinarily exposed to Indian tax on worldwide income.Given these consequences, even a small difference in the number of days regarded as spent in India can materially alter the tax treatment of an individual’s overseas income. Additionally, in recent times disclosure schedules in regard to overseas assets and the applicability of the Black Money Act for resident individuals are also an important factor which makes the residential status all the more relevant.The residence framework has traditionally relied heavily upon objective tests of physical presence prescribed under section 6 of the Income-tax Act, 1961 (“the 1961 Act”)1. Broadly, the framework may be illustrated as follows:SituationRelevant principle / thresholdGeneral residence testPresence in India for 182 days or moreAlternative general test60 days in the relevant year plus 365 days in the preceding four yearsIndian citizen leaving India for overseas employment60-day threshold generally substituted by 182 daysIndian citizen/PIO visiting India60-day threshold substituted by 182 days; reduced to 120 days where total income, other than income from foreign sources, exceeds INR 15 Lacs2Specified Indian citizen not liable to tax elsewhereDeemed resident where relevant Indian income exceeds INR 15 Lacs; treated as RNORThe Income-tax Act, 2025 (“the 2025 Act”), applicable from 1 April 2026, substantially retains this architecture, including the basic day-count tests, the overseas-employment and visitor relaxations, the 120-day rule and deemed residency. Importantly, the expression “being outside India, comes on a visit to India” also continues. Thus, the issues considered in recent rulings under the 1961 Act remain relevant under the 2025 Act.This seemingly straight forward position of residential status has of late been unsettled due to a host of judicial rulings which have dominated the landscape in recent times. An analysis of those rulings is essential to ensure that taxpayers continue to enjoy their non-residential status given the implications of being a resident as explained earlier.Counting Days in India: Which Days Are to Be Included?The residential status under Indian income-tax law had come to be settled after a while, as it involved counting the number of days an individual was physically present in India. Various judicial rulings had stressed the physical status of the individual as being relevant for determining the residential status. The only controversy that really remained was whether both the day of arrival and departure of an individual were to be considered in determining the status.An early ruling of the Authority for Advance Rulings (“AAR”)3 adopted a strict approach in this regard. The AAR held that, for calculating the period of stay in India, both the day on which the individual entered India and the day on which he left India were required to be taken into account. The reasoning was that, even though the individual might have been outside India for part of either day, he was nevertheless physically present in India for some part of that day.However, in recent times, based on the Karnataka High Court ruling in the case of Manoj Kumar Reddy Nare4 which has been followed by Tribunals across the country, there has been broad agreement that while considering the number of days for determining residential status, only one of the days, i.e., arrival or departure, needs to be considered. This approach is based, inter alia, on the principle contained in section 9 of the General Clauses Act, 18975, that while computing a period “from” a particular date, the first day is to be excluded. Accordingly, the day of arrival is excluded while computing the period of stay in India.This obviously leads to a beneficial position in cases where there is a photo finish to determine the final residential status.The residential status under Indian income-tax law had come to be settled after a while, as it involved counting the number of days an individual was physically present in India. Various judicial rulings had stressed the physical status of the individual as being relevant for determining the residential status.Does the nature of the visa determine the purpose of travel?Normally the nature of the visa obtained by the individual would not have been very significant in determining the residential status. However, a new angle has been brought in by the Chennai Tribunal’s 2025 decision in the case of M. Mahadevan6 which brings into focus the purpose for which he travels overseas. The taxpayer, popularly known as “Hot Breads Mahadevan”, who had substantial business interests in India and abroad, had claimed non-resident status on the ground that Explanation 1 to section 6(1)1 applied to him, as he had gone outside India for the purposes of business (i.e. employment to be interpreted widely, which included business).The controversy, amongst other issues which are germane, revolved around the relevance of the nature of the visa in determining the purpose of overseas travel.The taxpayer admittedly had business interests in jurisdictions including Singapore and Malaysia. The first appellate authority had accepted that his travels to those jurisdictions could be business-related notwithstanding that certain immigration permissions described the journeys as social or visitor travel. The taxpayer had in fact argued that repeated visits to jurisdictions where he had business interests suggested that they were not social or tourist visits but business visits, as no person would tour a place where he had already gone earlier repeatedly. The Tribunal, however, took a stricter view, treating the nature of the visas as relevant evidence and observing that merely having business interests abroad would not establish that every foreign journey was undertaken for business or employment.The ruling therefore raises an interesting question as to the weight to be attached to the stated purpose of travel under immigration law while determining residential status under income-tax law. While a visa constitutes relevant contemporaneous evidence, the visa category and the activities actually undertaken during a visit need not necessarily be determinative. It is well known that a visa is often determined by the regulations relating to immigration and other considerations, as may be determined by the respective country. One may often note that as far as people arriving in India are concerned, Indian embassies abroad have a differing stance on issuing employment/business/tourist visas, and that is not often necessarily determinative of the reason for travel.The ruling in Mahadevan nevertheless emphasises that the mere existence of overseas business interests is insufficient to characterise each foreign visit as business-related and the purpose of such travel would need to be supported by the relevant travel documents and contemporaneous evidence of the activities undertaken abroad to make the claim foolproof.Does the term “Being Outside India” Require Prior Non-Resident Status?Very recently, a new perspective on the interpretation of the term outside India was adopted by the Bangalore Tribunal’s ruling in Binny Bansal v. DCIT7. The ruling raises an important question concerning the scope of the relaxation available to an Indian citizen or person of Indian origin who, “being outside India, comes on a visit to India”. In the facts of the case, the taxpayer had relocated to Singapore for employment in February 2019 and spent 141 days in India during FY 2019-20, having spent more than 365 days in India during the preceding four years. Consequently, unless the relaxation under Explanation 1(b) to section 6(1)1 applied, he would satisfy the ordinary 60-day/365-day test of residence and be considered as a resident.The taxpayer contended that the expression “being outside India” refers to the physical situs of the individual and does not require him to have been a non-resident as per Section 61 in an earlier year. Having relocated to Singapore and thereafter travelled to India on visits, he argued that his residential status in an earlier year could not determine whether he was, as a matter of fact, “outside India” when he subsequently came to India on a visit. It was pointed out that the term that was used was “being outside India” as opposed to a “non-resident” which clearly indicated that the person need not be an NRI as per the Income Tax Act. A reference was made to the Circular of the Board8 that explained that the intention of the amendment was to provide an extended threshold to facilitate visits by NRIs and enable them to manage their investments, business interests and other affairs in India without losing their non-resident status.Unfortunately for the taxpayer, the Tribunal adopted a different interpretation. Referring, inter alia, to the legislative history of Explanation 1(b)1 and CBDT Circular No. 684 of 19948, it considered the relaxation to be intended for persons who were already non-residents and visited India without losing their non-resident status. It therefore denied the benefit to the taxpayer, who had been resident in India in the earlier year.With the utmost respect to the ruling of the Tribunal, there is considerable force in examining whether “being outside India” should receive a narrow interpretation. The reference to the explanation of section 115C9 in the Circular only provides a reference to a “person of Indian origin” and does not expressly import any additional requirement that the individual should already qualify as a non-resident under the Income-tax Act. Further, if the statutory language does not expressly require the individual to have been a non-resident in an earlier year, reading such a condition into the provision may therefore add a requirement which it does not expressly stipulate. More importantly, if the amendment was intended to enable NRIs residing overseas to participate in the Indian economy and manage their investments and business interests in India, the statutory language should arguably be interpreted in a manner that furthers, rather than unduly restricts, that object. A person who has genuinely moved and is living outside India should not necessarily cease to fall within the expression “being outside India” merely because the day-count rules resulted in his being classified as a resident in an earlier year.The ruling therefore brings into focus an interpretation of being “outside India” as used in the statute equated to being a “non-resident” as a consequence of the statutory day-count test. Whether the former necessarily imports the latter is an issue which will be argued in higher forums. In any case, the ruling puts in an extra layer of onus on being non-resident in an earlier year which will need to be factored.Interpretation of tax law always brings in new facets and a new perspective to existing beliefs. The test of residence, though founded on objective day-count rules, may involve important questions of evidence and statutory interpretation.Residence during Covid-19: Can the Law Compel the Impossible?The COVID-19 pandemic presented an unprecedented difficulty in the application of residence rules based upon physical presence. International flights were suspended, borders were closed or subject to severe restrictions, and, even as travel gradually resumed, its availability differed depending upon the destination and the arrangements then in force. Consequently, an individual who intended to leave India could, in a given case, remain physically present here not as a matter of choice, but because departure to the country in which he ordinarily resided or was transacting business was simply not possible.The exceptional nature of such presence raises the question of whether days spent in India because of an inability to leave should necessarily be equated with an ordinary voluntary stay. In that background, taxpayers may note the decision of the Delhi High Court in the case of CIT v. Suresh Nanda,10 which could provide guidance in that regard.The Delhi High Court’s decision in Suresh Nanda10 provides an important principle in this context. In that case, the taxpayer’s passport had been impounded, as a result of which he was unable to leave India, and his physical presence exceeded the statutory threshold of 182 days. The High Court upheld the exclusion of the period during which the taxpayer was compelled to remain in India, recognising that presence caused by circumstances beyond the individual’s control could not necessarily be treated in the same manner as a voluntary stay. Notably, the impounding of the passport was itself held to be unjustified, illegal and untenable, and this finding was not disputed by the Revenue. Consequently, the taxpayer’s excess stay in India was regarded as a consequence of compulsion rather than choice.The circumstances created by COVID-19 were, of course, different from the legal restraint involved in Suresh Nanda. However, the underlying principle assumes relevance: where an individual has the intention to leave India but is prevented from doing so by circumstances which make departure impossible, continued physical presence may not necessarily reflect a voluntary choice to remain in India.The CBDT itself recognised this difficulty and, through Circular No. 11/202011, provided specified relief in computing the period of stay in India for FY 2019-20 for individuals who had come to India on a visit and were unable to leave owing to quarantine, lockdown and the suspension of international flights. While the circular provided some relief, it has a lot of preconditions which are required to be met.Over and above the relief provided by the Circular, there is a more fundamental principle involved: The maxim is “LEX NON COGIT AD IMPOSSIBILIA” (Broom’s Legal Maxims - P.162) - the law does not compel a man to do that which he cannot possibly perform. This principle has been recognised by the Supreme Court in Raj Kumar Dey v. Tarapada Dey12 and, more recently, in Engineering Analysis Centre of Excellence (P.) Ltd.13. If an individual could not leave India because no practicable means of travelling to his country of residence was available, the law ought not ordinarily to proceed on the premise that he could nevertheless have departed merely because the statutory residence test is expressed by reference to physical presence.ConclusionTo conclude, it is important to keep a note of the rulings discussed above to ensure that there is no slip between the cup and the lip. Interpretation of tax law always brings in new facets and a new perspective to existing beliefs. The test of residence, though founded on objective day-count rules, may involve important questions of evidence and statutory interpretation. They also underscore the need to maintain reliable travel records, adequately substantiate the purpose of overseas travel and carefully consider the implications of visits to India. As the old maxim goes, “A stitch in time saves nine”. Similarly, one will need to keep in mind emerging rulings to ensure that planning for residence does not require too much of stitching or discovering new arguments at the time of the assessment.ReferencesIncome-tax Act, 1961Income-tax Act, 2025General Clauses Act, 1897Black Money (Undisclosed Foreign Income and Assets) and Imposition of Tax Act, 2015CBDT Circular No. 684 dated 10 June 1994CBDT Circular No. 11 of 2020 dated 8 May 2020, F. No. 370142/18/2020-TPLIn re, Petition No. 7 of 1995, [1997] 223 ITR 462 (AAR)Director of Income-tax (International Taxation) v. Manoj Kumar Reddy Nare, [2011] 245 CTR 350 (Karnataka)DCIT v. M. Mahadevan, [2025] 175 taxmann.com 383 (Chennai - Trib.)Binny Bansal v. DCIT, [2026] 182 taxmann.com 226 (Bangalore - Trib.)CIT v. Suresh Nanda, [2015] 375 ITR 172 (Delhi)Raj Kumar Dey v. Tarapada Dey, (1987) 4 SCC 398 (SC)Engineering Analysis Centre of Excellence (P.) Ltd. v. CIT, [2021] 432 ITR 471 (SC)Broom’s Legal MaximsAuthors may be reached at eboard@icai.inSection 6(1) of the 1961 Act provides that an individual is said to be resident in India in any previous year, if he –(a) is in India in that year for a period or periods amounting in all to 182 days or more; or(c) having within the four years preceding that year been in India for a period or periods amounting in all to 365 days or more, is in India for a period or periods amounting in all to 60 days or more in that year.Explanation 1 thereto, inter alia, substitutes the 60-day period with 182 days in the case of –(a) an Indian citizen leaving India as a member of the crew of an Indian ship or for the purposes of employment outside India(b) an Indian citizen/PIO who, “being outside India, comes on a visit to India”, with the 60-day period being substituted with 120 days where such individual’s total income, other than income from foreign sources, exceeds INR 15 lakh during the relevant previous year.Section 6(1A) provides for deemed residence of an Indian citizen having total income, other than income from foreign sources, exceeding INR 15 lakh, where he is not liable to tax in any other country or territory by reason of domicile, residence or other similar criteria. ↩Explanation 1 to Section 6(6) of the 1961 Act provides that for the purposes of this section, “income from foreign sources” means the income, which accrues or arises outside India (except income derived from a business controlled in or a profession set up in India) and which is not deemed to accrue or arise in India. ↩In re [1997] 223 ITR 462 (AAR) ↩Director of Income-tax (International Taxation) v. Manoj Kumar Reddy Nare [2011] 245 CTR 350 (Karnataka) ↩Section 9(1) of the General Clauses Act, 1897: In any Central Act or Regulation made after the commencement of this Act, it shall be sufficient, for the purpose of excluding the first in a series of days or any other period of time, to use the word ‘from’, and, for the purpose of including the last in a series of days or any other period of time, to use the word ‘to’. ↩DCIT v. M. Mahadevan [2025] 175 taxmann.com 383 (Chennai - Trib.) ↩Binny Bansal v. DCIT [2026] 182 taxmann.com 226 (Bangalore - Trib.) ↩CBDT Circular No. 684 dated 10 June 1994, paras 19 - 19.3 ↩Section 115C(e) of the 1961 Act provides that “non-resident Indian” means an individual, being a citizen of India or a person of Indian origin who is not a “resident”. The Explanation thereto provides that a person shall be deemed to be of Indian origin if he, or either of his parents or any of his grandparents, was born in undivided India. ↩CIT v. Suresh Nanda [2015] 375 ITR 172 (Delhi) ↩CBDT Circular No. 11 of 2020 dated 8 May 2020, F. No. 370142/18/2020-TPL ↩Raj Kumar Dey v. Tarapada Dey (1987) 4 SCC 398 (SC) ↩Engineering Analysis Centre of Excellence (P.) Ltd. v. CIT [2021] 432 ITR 471 (SC) ↩The Chartered Accountant | www.icai.org | November 2026 | pp. 16–19
Ep. 551 — Critical Issues in the Taxation of Individuals’ Global Mobility and the Interplay of Double Taxation Avoidance Agreements (DTAAs)
CA Journal
00:00--:--
Critical Issues in the Taxation of Individuals’ Global Mobility and the Interplay of Double Taxation Avoidance Agreements (DTAAs)Global mobility involves the cross-border movement of employees, professionals, executives, and business personnel for work assignments, projects, secondments, transfers, or remote work. Previously, it often meant sending employees abroad for fixed periods. Today, it encompasses extended expatriate postings, short business trips, cross-border secondments, international transfers, commuter roles, remote work from abroad, virtual assignments, and global talent hiring.With multinational expansion and the rise of remote work, global mobility has become central to international tax and workforce strategy. Managing it requires coordinating cross-border employee movement for both short-term and permanent roles. From a tax perspective, this includes employment law, immigration, payroll, personal taxation, social security, transfer pricing, corporate tax, and navigating Double Taxation Avoidance Agreements (DTAAs). At its core, global mobility raises a fundamental question:When an individual works across borders, which country has the right to tax their income, to what extent, and how is double taxation avoided?Resolving this requires more than identifying the country issuing the paycheck. It involves assessing residential status, work location, employer, income source, treaty provisions, foreign tax credits, payroll obligations, and the relevance of permanent establishment and transfer pricing rules.Residence and the Source of SalaryAn individual may be a resident of India in one year and a non-resident in another. The question is whether a change in residential status alters taxability or leaves it unchanged. Determining an individual’s residential status is, therefore, the starting point for testing the taxability of their income. If the individual is a resident, India taxes their global income under Section 5(1) of the Income-tax Act, 2025. If the individual is a non-resident of India, taxability is limited under Section 5(2) to income received or deemed to be received in India, or income that accrues or arises, or is deemed to accrue or arise, in India. Thus, the taxation of mobile employees depends on the interplay between residential status and the source of income.Under Section 6 of the Income-tax Act, 2025, a person is a resident of India if they are in India for 182 days or more in a tax year, or for 60 days in that year and 365 days in the preceding four years. For Indian citizens or Persons of Indian Origin (PIO) visiting India, the 60-day threshold extends to 182 days (or 120 days if Indian-sourced income exceeds ₹15 lakhs).If an individual is a resident of both contracting states under domestic tax law, the DTAA provides a residency test based on the tie-breaker. Another critical concept is ‘split residency’, often utilised in the year of relocation. While Indian domestic law under the Income-tax Act, 2025, determines residential status for the entire financial year as a single, indivisible unit, DTAAs allow for a more granular application. As seen in Raman Chopra v. Dy. CIT [2016] 69 taxmann.com 452 (Delhi - Trib.), the treaty tie-breaker tests under Article 4(2) can be applied to specific periods within a tax year. This allows a taxpayer to be a resident of one country for part of the year and another for the remainder, effectively shielding foreign-sourced income earned during the non-resident period from Indian taxation, despite having a ‘Resident and Ordinarily Resident’ (ROR) status under domestic law for the full year.In Binny Bansal v. DCIT [2026] 182 taxmann.com 226 (Bangalore - Trib.), the decision emphasises that the ‘centre of vital interests’ test is increasingly qualitative rather than merely quantitative. If an individual has physically relocated and established a home abroad, deep-rooted economic ties, such as significant immovable property, active business involvement, or substantial loans to Indian entities, can result in the individual being deemed a treaty resident of India. A distinction is drawn between ‘active’ economic engagement (running a business) and ‘passive’ investments (bank accounts or mutual funds), with the former carrying significantly more weight in residency disputes.“Under Section 6 of the Income-tax Act, 2025, a person is a resident of India if they are in India for 182 days or more in a tax year, or for 60 days in that year and 365 days in the preceding four years.”A change in residential status also has practical consequences. For returning NRIs, it is advisable to redesignate NRE/NRO accounts as resident accounts immediately to avoid compliance defaults, noting that interest on NRE accounts becomes taxable immediately upon a change in residency status.Once residential status is settled, the next question is where the salary is earned. Section 9(3)(a) of the Income-tax Act, 2025 (corresponding to Section 9(1)(ii) of the Income-tax Act, 1961) provides that income under the head “Salaries” is deemed to accrue or arise in India if it is earned in India. The statute clarifies that salary for services rendered in India is treated as income earned in India, irrespective of the place of receipt or the residential status at the time of receipt. Salary income, including ESOP perquisites, is therefore deemed to accrue in India if earned for services rendered in India. Since salary is taxed on a due basis, it will be deemed to accrue or arise in India if the service is rendered there.The courts have strictly interpreted this ‘place of performance’ test to require physical presence. In the landmark ruling of Clifford Chance vs. Deputy Commissioner of Income-tax, Circle 2(6), Mumbai [2009] 176 Taxman 458 (Bombay) / [2009] 318 ITR 237 (Bombay) / [2009] 221 CTR 1 (Bombay) [19-12-2008], the Hon’ble High Court held that for a non-resident to be taxed, services must be rendered in India. This ‘territorial nexus’ is vital. Similarly, in Santanu Sanyal vs. ACIT [2024] 165 taxmann.com 390 (Kolkata - Trib.) [23-07-2024], it was held that foreign allowances received by a non-resident for services rendered outside India do not fall within the scope of total income under Section 5(2), even if paid by an Indian employer. This principle is further reinforced in Kachana Raghunatha Reddy vs. DCIT/ACIT [2026] 189 taxmann.com 512 (Bangalore - Trib.) [12-08-2026], where the tribunal remanded the matter to verify services rendered in Korea, noting that salary for foreign services cannot be taxed in India merely because an Indian company has paid the salary and deducted TDS.At the same time, commentaries on global mobility caution against automatically assuming that lump-sum living allowances or social security-related reimbursements are tax-exempt. In Sun Outsourcing Solutions (P.) Ltd. v. CIT [2018] 92 taxmann.com 339, it was clarified that payments intended to meet personal expenses or higher costs of living abroad constitute taxable perquisites and do not qualify for the ‘official duty’ exemption under Section 10(14)(ii) of the Income-tax Act, 1961 (corresponding to Schedule III (13) of the Income-tax Act, 2025).ESOPs and Social Security: Income Spread Across Years and CountriesTwo kinds of income pose special difficulty for mobile employees, because they build up over several years during which the employee may have worked, and been resident, in more than one country. These are ESOPs and social security benefits.Under the Income-tax Act, 2025, the primary charging provision for ESOPs is Section 17(1)(d) (corresponding to Section 17(2)(vi) of the Income-tax Act, 1961). This section defines ‘perquisite’ to include the value of any specified security or sweat equity shares allotted or transferred, directly or indirectly, by the current or former employer, free or at a concessional rate. ESOPs are valued as perquisites at exercise, based on Fair Market Value (FMV) under Rule 15 of the Income-tax Rules, 2026. Although vesting is not the taxable event, the option value increases even in years when the employee rendered services outside India. The challenge in ESOP taxation arises when the year of vesting and the year of exercise are different, and the individual is resident in the year of vesting and non-resident in the year of exercise, or vice versa.The question, then, is which country has the right to tax when the option value increases during the years in which the employee rendered services outside India. The OECD publication “The taxation of employee stock options” states that:“Where the employment services to which a stock-option relates have been provided in more than one State, an allocation rule is necessary for the application of Article 15 and Articles 23A and 23B. A logical allocation method would be to attribute the employment benefit attributable to a stock-option to services performed in a particular country in proportion to the number of days during which employment has been exercised in that country, to the total number of days during which the employment from which the stock-option is derived has been exercised.”Indian courts have followed the same logic. The statutory valuation of ESOPs under Rule 15 of the 2026 Rules is often complicated by cross-border movement, and the judiciary resolved this by applying the ‘vesting period’ allocation. In Assistant Commissioner of Income-tax, Circle-48(1) vs. Robert Arthur Keltz [2013] 35 taxmann.com 424 (Delhi - Trib.) / [2013] 59 SOT 203 (Delhi - Trib.) [24-05-2013], affirmed by the Delhi High Court, it was held that where an employee was in India for only part of the ESOP vesting period, only the proportion of the perquisite attributable to service rendered in India is taxable.Conversely, if the services were rendered in India but the exercise occurs while the individual is a non-resident, India retains the right to tax the India-leg portion. In Unnikrishnan V S vs. Income-tax Officer, International Taxation 4(3)(1), Mumbai [2021] 123 taxmann.com 238 (Mumbai - Trib.) [13-01-2021], the tribunal held that ESOP benefits relate to the time of grant and the period of service. Since the qualifying services were rendered in India, the income was taxable in India despite the assessee’s non-resident status at the time of exercise.The position becomes more complex when the employee changes residence during the vesting period. The OECD publication on “The taxation of employee stock options” addresses such multiple residence taxation, which says:“Where an employee who is a resident of one State is taxed as a non-resident in another State, Article 23 provides relief from any double taxation. However, an employee might reside in different countries at the time an option is granted, at the time it vests, at the time it is exercised, and at the time the shares acquired with the option are sold. All of these countries may claim the right to tax as States of residence, and if each of them taxes the benefit from the stock option at the time the taxpayer is a resident of that country, there will be multiple residence taxation. While Article 23 deals with residence-source double taxation, it does not provide relief for all cases of residence-residence double taxation. The risks of multiple residence taxation may be compounded in the case of countries that have a “departure tax” on capital gains, i.e., countries that deem capital gains to be realised when a person ceases to be a resident or that maintain, through their tax conventions, a right to tax capital gains of former residents.”“The situs of accrual for salary and related social security benefits is the place where services are rendered. If an employee works outside India, the right to receive salary and social security contributions arises outside India.”Social security contributions and benefits raise a similar problem of time and place. For tax purposes, the treatment of social security is complex due to the situs of accrual and the point of receipt. Employer and employee contributions are made in one year, but the right to receive benefits arises in different years. If the employee was resident in some years and non-resident in others during the contribution period, how will it be accrued during the contribution period and at the time of withdrawal of benefits?The distinction between the ‘accrual’ of salary and its ‘receipt’ in India is vital for employees on deputation who may maintain NRE accounts. The situs of accrual for salary and related social security benefits is the place where services are rendered. If an employee works outside India, the right to receive salary and social security contributions arises outside India. Mere remittance of such funds into an Indian NRE account does not trigger taxability under Section 5(2)(a), as the ‘first point of receipt’ is the foreign location where the employee acquired the lawful right to the money. This supports the view that India should not tax mandatory foreign social security contributions solely because funds move through Indian banking channels.Under the Income-tax Act, 2025, employer contributions to foreign social security funds are generally taxable as perquisites under Section 17(1)(h) because such funds typically do not qualify as ‘approved’ or ‘recognised’ funds under the Indian law. The specific ₹7.50 lakhs threshold under Section 17(1)(h) applies only to Indian statutory funds (RPF, NPS, and approved superannuation funds) and not to foreign funds. Employee contributions to foreign funds are generally ineligible for deduction under Section 123 or Section 124, as they are not ‘notified’ schemes. Withdrawals are taxable as ‘profits in lieu of salary’ under Section 18(1)(c)(ii) to the extent of the employer’s contribution and interest.However, Section 158 of the Income-tax Act, 2025 (corresponding to Section 89A of the Income-tax Act, 1961) provides critical relief for income accrued in a specified retirement account in a notified country. Under Rule 74 of the Income-tax Rules, 2026 (corresponding to Rule 21AAA of the Income-tax Rules, 1962), a resident who opened the account while being a non-resident can opt to defer Indian taxation until the year of withdrawal or redemption in the foreign country. This mechanism primarily addresses the timing mismatch in taxation.Regarding retirement benefits, the judiciary aligns with the principle that past services rendered outside India while being a non-resident cannot be taxed in India upon receipt. In Commissioner of Income-tax vs. Anant Jain [2012] 21 taxmann.com 19 (Delhi) / [2012] 207 Taxman 117 (Delhi) [24-04-2012], the High Court held that retirement benefits received from a US employer for services rendered in the US were not taxable in India for a ‘Not Ordinarily Resident’. For residents, Section 158 of the 2025 Act provides relief. In Jignesh Naresh Jariwala vs. Deputy Director of Income-tax, CPC, Bengaluru [2025] 178 taxmann.com 233 (Mumbai - Trib.) / [2025] 214 ITD 585 (Mumbai - Trib.) [04-09-2025], the tribunal clarified that once an option is exercised via Form 10EE (now Form No. 40) in one year, it continues to apply to subsequent years. Relief cannot be denied on procedural grounds for not re-filing the form annually.Relieving Double TaxationEven after applying these rules, an employee on deputation may face double taxation due to the timing of accrual and receipt of income, the place of rendering services, and residential status. To avoid double taxation, the employee can claim foreign tax credit (FTC) in the resident country. Under the Income-tax Act, 2025, FTC is available under Section 160. As per Rule 76 of the Income-tax Rules, 2026 (corresponding to Rule 128 of the Income-tax Rules, 1962), residents paying tax abroad can claim credit in India by filing Form No. 44 (corresponding to Form 67). The two areas where FTC matters most for resident employees on deputation outside India are ESOPs and social security benefits.If ESOP income (perquisite value) is taxed in India (as salary) and in the foreign country (e.g., at vesting, exercise, or sale), the employee is eligible to claim foreign tax credit. DTAA articles on “Dependent Personal Services” (e.g., Article 15 of the India-UAE DTAA, Article 16 of the India-USA DTAA, Article 15 of the India-Germany DTAA), as seen in Hewlett Packard India Software Operation (P.) Ltd., [2018] 91 taxmann.com 473 (AAR - New Delhi), determine the taxing rights of the residence and source states for employment income, including ESOPs. DTAA provisions are crucial in determining whether ESOP income is taxable in the foreign country and, consequently, whether it is eligible for FTC in India. Since India and the foreign country may tax the same ESOP benefit in different years, the timing of the tax matters. The OECD publication on the taxation of employee stock option schemes states that:“The provisions of the Convention that allow the State of source to tax particular items of income or capital do not provide any restriction as to when such tax is to be levied. Since both Articles 23 A and 23 B require that relief be granted where the State of source may tax an item of income or capital in accordance with the provisions of the Convention, it follows that such relief must be provided regardless of when the tax is levied by the State of source. The State of residence must therefore provide relief of double taxation through the credit or exemption method with respect to such item of income or capital even though the State of source taxes it in an earlier or later year. Some States, however, do not follow the wording of Article 23A or 23B in their bilateral conventions and link the relief of double taxation they provide under tax conventions to what their domestic laws provide. These countries, however, would be expected to seek other ways (the mutual agreement procedure, for example) to relieve the double taxation which might otherwise arise in cases where the State of source levies tax in a different taxation year.”The same principles apply to social security benefits. As discussed earlier, employer contributions to foreign social security funds are generally taxable as perquisites in India, and withdrawals are taxable as ‘profits in lieu of salary’ under Section 18(1)(c)(ii) of the Income-tax Act, 2025. If these social security benefits (e.g., pension, lump-sum withdrawals) are received by a resident employee on deputation and are taxed in the foreign country, they would generally be eligible for foreign tax credit. The deferral relief under Section 158, discussed earlier, addresses the timing mismatch. Where social security benefits are taxed in India upon withdrawal and also taxed in the foreign country, the foreign tax paid on such benefits would be eligible for tax credit. For instance, in Jaspal Singh Bindra vs. Deputy Commissioner of Income-tax, [2025] 170 taxmann.com 80 (Kolkata - Trib.) [19-11-2024], the ITAT allowed FTC for pension income earned from a UK pension fund, taxed in the UK and also offered to be taxed in India. This case highlights that pension/social security benefits, when doubly taxed, are eligible for FTC.Finally, the specific DTAA with the country of deputation would also play a significant role. Many DTAAs contain articles on “Pensions and Social Security Payments” that may allocate taxing rights or provide for credit. The more beneficial provisions of either the DTAA or the Income-tax Act would apply.ConclusionTaxing global mobility is now a complex mix of residential status, place of performance, source rules, DTAAs, ESOPs, social security, and foreign tax credits. To determine what is taxable, one must look not only at the employer’s country and the country of residence but also at the place of performance, which plays a significant role in determining each country’s taxing right. Ongoing issues include changes in residence during the year, ESOP taxes after working in different countries, and social security that covers several countries and years. These factors can cause timing differences, double taxation, and extra compliance work. The OECD notes that new types of cross-border and remote work bring more uncertainty. The challenges are not limited to the taxation of ESOPs or the taxation of social security benefits. Work-from-anywhere and digital automation have fundamentally altered the global work landscape. Multinationals implementing work-from-anywhere policies face complex mobility compliance challenges, such as tracking employees’ location (i.e., their physical presence). Because of digital automation, it is sometimes very difficult to track where the employee is rendering services. Further, the concept of an employer has been the subject of significant judicial interpretation in India. Tax authorities and courts have adopted an economic employer test, i.e. looking beyond the formal legal arrangement to identify who bears the economic risk, exercises control, and derives the benefit of employees’ services. Another challenge is the risk of creating a permanent establishment (PE) in the other contracting state. Deploying employees outside India may create a PE in that country if the conditions in Article 5 of the OECD Model Convention are met. To make global mobility taxation effective, the Government should implement robust foreign tax credit systems and effective dispute-resolution mechanisms. In the end, global mobility is not just about the movement of people, but also income, tax rights, duties, and risks, making it a key topic in international tax.◆◆◆Author may be reached ateboard@icai.inThe Chartered Accountant · November 2026 www.icai.org · pp. 612–615
Ep. 552 — Is the Profit Split Method Becoming the New Transactional Net Margin Method? Evolution of Transfer Pricing in the Post-BEPS Era
CA Journal
00:00--:--
Is the Profit Split Method Becoming the New Transactional Net Margin Method? Evolution of Transfer Pricing in the Post-BEPS EraIn the Indian Transfer Pricing (“TP”) environment, the Transactional Net Margin Method (“TNMM”) is the most frequently used method, both by taxpayers and by the tax authorities. The Profit Split Method (“PSM”), on the other hand, has generally been reserved for transactions involving unique intangibles, or for cases where each party brings unique and valuable contributions. In the Indian transfer pricing practice, TNMM has been widely applied, particularly for benchmarking routine services, manufacturing and distribution transactions. However, selection of the most appropriate method (MAM) depends on the facts and circumstances of each transaction.The OECD / G20 project on Base Erosion and Profit Shifting (“BEPS”) has changed the focus. The question now is where value is created, and TP outcomes ought to be aligned with that. Under Action Plans 8-10, entities performing Development, Enhancement, Maintenance, Protection and Exploitation (“DEMPE”) functions in relation to intangibles must be remunerated for those functions. PSM may be appropriate where the parties make unique and valuable contributions or meet other relevant conditions for applying the method. Hard-to-value intangibles (“HTVI”) should also be analysed with rigorous TP analysis.1The OECD’s June 2026 consultation draft proposing revisions to Chapter VII of its Transfer Pricing Guidelines, dealing with intra-group services, further emphasises the importance of selecting the most appropriate transfer pricing method based on the facts and circumstances of each transaction. The draft clarifies that cost-based methods, such as the Cost Plus Method or cost-based TNMM, should not automatically be preferred for intra-group services. Instead, the selection should consider the economically relevant characteristics of the services, including the use of unique and valuable intangibles and the risk profiles of the parties. However, the proposed revisions do not establish any preference for PSM or change the underlying principles of method selection. They reinforce the need to evaluate each transaction on its merits.2This article looks at that question. The author’s view is that TNMM is not going anywhere, and it will remain the most widely used method for routine transactions that can be reliably benchmarked. What is changing is that PSM is receiving greater attention in cases involving complex and highly integrated transactions, including circumstances where a residual profit split may be considered after determining routine returns. Indian Tax Tribunals (“ITAT”) have gone both ways on this. They have accepted a PSM for integrated operations (Global One India Private Limited3, Infogain India Private Limited4) and rejected it for a licensed manufacturer performing routine functions (Toyota Boshoku Automotive India Private Limited5).IntroductionTNMM has been selected as the MAM in the majority of cases for a long time. It is easy to apply, as comparable companies are selected from commercial benchmarking databases after quantitative filters and qualitative analysis, and their net operating margins are compared with those of the tested party. Taxpayers and tax officers have regarded this as the MAM for testing simpler functions. In India, captive service providers, contract manufacturers and limited-risk distributors are predominantly large in number, and almost all of them have been benchmarked using TNMM.The BEPS Action Plans 8-10 recommendations placed greater emphasis on accurately delineating controlled transactions by examining contractual arrangements alongside the parties’ actual conduct, including the functions performed, assets used and risks assumed and controlled.6In today’s era, businesses are different from the ones TNMM was designed to apply. A few years ago, a typical Multinational Group made its key decisions at headquarters, owned its intellectual property in one place and used its overseas subsidiaries mainly to carry out instructions. This model is fading. It is now seen that research may happen in one country, product development in another, data analytics in a third and key commercial decisions somewhere else. Functions, assets and risks are now spread across the Group, and the entities often depend on each other to earn a profit. Where different entities make unique and valuable contributions, or where their activities and risks are so closely integrated that their contributions cannot be reliably evaluated separately, a one-sided method such as TNMM may not provide the most reliable result. In such circumstances, PSM should be evaluated alongside other potentially appropriate methods.Why TNMM Became the Preferred MethodTNMM became the preferred method because, in most cases, it gives a more reliable result than the other methods, mainly because reliable comparable data is available. Close comparables to traditional methods are often hard to find, as they require stringent comparability. TNMM tests net margins, which are less affected by small differences in products and functions, so it can be applied with reasonable confidence across a wide range of transactions. That reliability, together with its practicality, is why taxpayers and tax authorities have relied on it. However, TNMM works best when the tested party performs routine functions and the other party contributes most of the value. As businesses become more integrated and more entities contribute to the same profit, TNMM may not capture the full picture.7Let’s take a simple example. An Indian captive software entity provides coding and testing services to its foreign associated enterprise. It owns no intellectual property, bears little risk and is remunerated at a cost-plus 15% mark-up. If its operating costs are INR 100 crore, it earns INR 15 crore as its operating profit. If the uncontrolled comparable companies providing software services selected from the commercial databases earn mark-ups in the range of 12% to 18%, the tested party’s mark-up of 15% can be considered to meet the arm’s length test as per the Indian TP regulations. The analysis is simple, given the availability of data on commercial databases.The OECD TP Guidelines of 1995 in paragraph 3.49 gave preference to the traditional transaction methods over profit-based methods.8 The 2010 revision did away with the preference for traditional transaction methods and replaced the hierarchy with a “MAM”. In practice, this allowed taxpayers and tax administrations to settle on whichever method was simplest to apply and suited the facts of the case. In India, the TP cases so far have largely been about captive Information Technology (“IT”) and IT-enabled service providers, BPO entities, contract research and contract manufacturing entities and limited-risk distributors. Benchmarking these entities has typically involved running a search on Indian databases for companies with a similar functional profile. In my experience, this is why TNMM has ended up being applied in the large majority of Indian TP cases.Where TNMM Falls ShortThat is only one side of the analysis. TNMM is considered the MAM where the entity performs simpler functions. It is not considered the preferred method where both parties to the international transaction contribute to the intangibles. Consider a Pharmaceutical Group. The parent entity develops new molecules and is the owner of the intellectual property (which includes the patents). On the other hand, the Indian subsidiary undertakes clinical trials, deputes its scientists to global projects, obtains key regulatory approvals and builds knowledge of the local market. Both the parent and the Indian subsidiary contribute to the profit that the Pharmaceutical Group earns. If the Indian subsidiary is still treated as a routine service provider and remunerated on a cost-plus arm’s length mark-up basis, its remuneration will not be aligned with the actual conduct of the Indian subsidiary. This is the kind of case where PSM should be considered the MAM.How DEMPE Changed the AnalysisThe DEMPE framework has changed how intangibles are analysed. In the pre-BEPS era, the legal owner of an intangible generally retained the residual profits/losses. After the introduction of Action Plans 8-10, this position has changed. The key question now is which entity performs and controls the important functions in the value chain. Take a Software Group where the parent entity is the legal owner of the code. A team of engineers employed in the Indian subsidiary improves the code, a team of researchers in the US subsidiary builds new features, a team of data scientists in Singapore refines the algorithms, and strategic decisions are taken by the European entity. On the facts of this case, should all the profit go to the legal owner? Post-BEPS, the answer is likely no. Where several entities perform DEMPE functions for developing intangibles, it becomes hard to argue that any one of the entities is performing the simpler functions and can be considered the tested party. It may be reiterated that DEMPE performance, control of economically significant risks and funding must be evaluated together.Integrated Business ModelsIntegrated Business Models are common in Multinational Enterprises, for example in pharmaceutical R&D, platform businesses, semiconductors, global networks and supply chain hubs. In these businesses, profit is rarely earned by one entity and then passed on to the others. More often, the entities collaborate to generate the return.Transaction-by-transaction analysis: Aggregating several transactions under a single TNMM analysis does not stop the tax officer from looking at any one of them separately. In Tupperware India Private Limited9, the taxpayer had aggregated its dealings with Group companies and applied TNMM as the MAM. The tax officer accepted the other international transactions but picked out a payment of INR 90 lakh made to a US Group entity for intra-group services and determined its arm’s length price at nil on the ground that there was not enough evidence to satisfy the need-benefit test. The ITAT observed that an agreement and invoices do not, by themselves, prove that services were actually rendered, and sent the matter back to the tax officer to verify the need-benefit test documentation. The case does not involve a PSM, but it does show a limitation of an aggregated, one-sided TNMM approach.This brings us to a basic question. Can a one-sided TNMM analysis test capture value creation when several entities jointly contribute to the profit? In many audits, taxpayers continue to defend routine returns under TNMM even though the tested party analysis does not deal with the main value drivers. That gap is what has driven the growing interest in PSM.OECD’s Growing Acceptance of PSMFor a long time, PSM was treated as a last resort, used only when traditional methods were not considered appropriate.10 This changed in 2010, when the OECD dropped the idea of a strict order of methods. It now asks taxpayers to pick the method that best suits the facts of each case.11 The BEPS project went further, saying profits should follow the place where value is created, and not just as per the agreements between Group companies.12 Then in June 2018, the OECD issued revised guidance on the PSM. It says a PSM is likely to be suitable where each party makes unique and valuable contributions, or where the business is so closely integrated that the parties’ contributions can’t be assessed separately.13 Further, the shared assumption of economically significant risks, or separate assumption of closely related risks, are important factors when considering PSM. The guidance also says the method shouldn’t normally be used where one party performs only simpler functions. So, the OECD isn’t saying PSM is the new default. It’s saying the method has become a normal, accepted method when the facts call for it.Industries Where PSM Is Gaining GroundThe application of PSM is not uniform across industries. It is applied in the following sectors:Pharmaceuticals: Drug development is among the most integrated activities in any business. Research, clinical trials, regulatory approvals and commercial launch are often spread across several countries. Where each Group entity contributes to a joint research and development effort, a PSM is considered to be a more appropriate method.Technology: Global technology businesses typically derive their value from algorithms, data, customer networks and intellectual property developed in several countries at the same time. Allocating routine returns to individual entities under TNMM cannot be considered a fair allocation of profits.The same applies to platform businesses, where network effects are created by users, engineers and marketers in different locations. A captive software centre that grows from back-end coding into end-to-end delivery, as in Infogain India Private Limited, sits on this boundary.Telecom and media: Global telecom networks and broadcasting Groups earn revenue only because many entities across many countries each perform a part of the work. The Global One India Private Limited and Star Group14 rulings both come from these sectors.What Are Courts Saying?The ITAT has decided a fair number of cases on whether PSM is the MAM, as tabulated below:RulingWho relied on a splitDecisionGlobal One India P Ltd (Supra)Company (residual split)PSM upheld over TPO’s TNMMInfogain India P Ltd (Supra)Company (40:60 split)PSM upheld; sent back, 40:60 ratio not to be disturbed on same factsIndiaNIC Infotech Ltd (ITA No. 1639/Ahd/2024)CompanyPSM upheld by acknowledging that the AE and the Company contributed to generating revenueFractal Analytics Pvt Ltd (ITA No. 764/MUM/2026)Company as well as Tax OfficeRPSM is accepted as the MAM for the integrated IT-enabled/data analytics services transactionThe pattern across these rulings is fairly consistent. The ITAT raises a fundamental question as to whether each party makes a unique contribution and whether the operations are integrated. Further, in Global One, the Tribunal distinguished between benchmarking routine returns and allocating residual profits where reliable external comparable information was difficult to obtain. In the case of Infogain, the Tribunal accepted PSM because the Indian and US entities performed interlinked functions and contributed significantly to the value chain. Acceptance of PSM in preceding and succeeding years was also relevant. In cases where the operations are highly integrated, a PSM may be accepted, and in cases where they are not, TNMM is generally considered the MAM.Is PSM Really the New TNMM?This is where the debate needs the most care, and there are good arguments on both sides. The answer is not a simple yes or no.The arguments for PSM are strong. TNMM asks whether one entity earns an arm’s length net profit margin, whereas PSM asks how the combined profits should be divided between the parties based on their respective contributions to value creation. This makes PSM relevant for highly integrated businesses, unique intangibles and cases where reliable external comparables are unavailable. Global One India Private Limited and Infogain India Private Limited show that PSM can succeed in India where a TNMM-based approach falls short.TNMM will continue to dominate routine services, contract manufacturing and limited-risk distribution. But where a business is highly integrated, relies on unique intangibles or creates significant value jointly, a PSM is likely to be found more appropriate in a growing number of cases.PSM has its limitations, though. It needs reliable combined financial data and a sound basis for allocating the profit. Sony Pictures Films India Private Limited15 shows that an attribution of percentages without proper support cannot lead to an appropriate conclusion, while Infogain India Private Limited shows that assigning weightages based on evidence and applied consistently over the years can survive scrutiny. Toyota Boshoku Automotive India Private Limited is a reminder that PSM cannot take the place of TNMM for routine transactions where one party performs limited functions and operations are not integrated.So, is PSM the new TNMM? Not across the board. TNMM will continue to dominate routine services, contract manufacturing and limited-risk distribution. But where a business is highly integrated, relies on unique intangibles or creates significant value jointly, a PSM is likely to be found more appropriate in a growing number of cases.India’s TP Landscape: The Next DecadeIn principle, India’s TP regulations leave room for PSM to play a bigger role. Section 165 of the Income-tax Act, 2025 (“the Act, 2025”), corresponding to Section 92C of the Income-tax Act, 1961 (“the Act, 1961”), does not rank the methods, and Rule 80 of the Income-tax Rules, 2026 (“the Rules, 2026”), corresponding to Rule 10C of the Income-tax Rules, 1962 (“the Rules, 1962”), requires the MAM to be selected having regard to the nature of the transaction, the functions performed, assets used and risks assumed, and the availability of reliable data. The difficulty lies in Rule 79(1)(d) of the Rules, 2026, corresponding to Rule 10B(1)(d) of the Rules, 1962, which refers to reliable external market data for evaluating the relative contribution of each enterprise. This can make PSM hard to apply where there is no external benchmark. Even so, Global One India Private Limited and Infogain India Private Limited show that the ITAT will accept a contribution-based split where the taxpayer lays down a solid factual and analytical foundation.The wider environment is also changing. Amount B under Pillar One provides a simplified, formula-based return for baseline marketing and distribution activities, which could shift more attention to non-routine profits. India has not adopted Amount B so far, but the direction is clear. Routine returns are increasingly being standardised, and disputes are likely to centre on intangibles, DEMPE and residual value.Over the next decade, taxpayers should expect closer scrutiny of DEMPE functions, marketing intangibles, location-specific advantages and integrated value chains. The ITAT’s verdict in Tupperware also shows that an individual transaction can be examined separately, even where the taxpayer has applied TNMM on an aggregated basis. Bilateral and multilateral Advance Pricing Agreements (“APAs”) and the Mutual Agreement Procedure (“MAP”) are likely to become more important for complex arrangements, where both tax administrations need to agree on the profit pool and the allocation key.For taxpayers, the practical takeaway is: do not assume that the Indian entity is either purely routine or automatically a co-owner of the value. The method must follow the factual analysis. Where PSM is appropriate, the analysis should be supported by functional interviews, clearly identified value drivers, well-reasoned weightages and consistency from year to year. For high-value or highly integrated arrangements, it is worth considering an APA to obtain certainty.ConclusionThe real question is not whether PSM will replace TNMM. It is whether a one-sided analysis is still sufficient when businesses are as closely integrated as they are today.For routine transactions undertaken by limited-risk entities, TNMM is likely to remain the dominant method and, in many cases, the best one. It brought practicality and consistency to a difficult area of tax, which is why it became the default. However, the business environment in which it earned that position has changed. Multinational Groups now create value through collaborative innovation, data, technology and intangibles developed across borders. In that context, a routine profit for one entity is often considered a one-sided analysis.In my view, the future of TP will not belong to either method on its own. What will matter is choosing the analysis that best reflects how value is actually created within the Group.——◆◆——Author may be reached at eboard@icai.inFootnotesOECD/G20 BEPS (2015), Aligning TP Outcomes with Value Creation, Actions 8-10 – 2015 Final Reports, Chapter VIParagraph 7.52 of the OECD’s June 2026 consultation documentITA No. 5571/Del/2011 and ITA No. 5896/Del/2012ITA No. 6134/Del/2012ITA No. 1646/Bang/2017 and 2586/Bang/2019OECD/G20 BEPS (2015), Aligning Transfer Pricing Outcomes with Value Creation, Actions 8-10 – 2015 Final Reports, Chapter VIRule 79(1)(e) of the Income-tax Rules, 2026, corresponding to Rule 10B(1)(e) Income-tax Rules, 1962OECD TP Guidelines for Multinational Enterprises and Tax Administrations (1995), Chapter III, para. 3.49, p. III-16.ITA No. 2333/Del/2019OECD, TP Guidelines for Multinational Enterprises and Tax Administrations (1995), Chapter IIIOECD, TP Guidelines for Multinational Enterprises and Tax Administrations (2010), Chapter II, Part I.OECD, Aligning TP Outcomes with Value Creation, Actions 8–10 – 2015 Final Reports, OECD/G20 BEPS Project.OECD, Revised Guidance on the Application of the Transactional PSM: Inclusive Framework on BEPS – Action 10 (June 2018). It now forms part of Chapter II, Part III, Section C of the OECD Transfer Pricing Guidelines (2022).ITA No. 8683/Mum/2011ITA No. 554/MUM/2022The Chartered Accountant — Theme November 2026 | www.icai.org
Ep. 553 — The Singapore–UAE Shield: Mutual Fund Gains Beyond India’s Tax Reach and Who Else Gets One
CA Journal
00:00--:--
The Singapore–UAE Shield: Mutual Fund Gains Beyond India's Tax Reach and Who Else Gets OneSingapore and the UAE hold two of the largest pools of NRI and institutional money in India; this article examines how capital gains on the sale of units of an Indian mutual fund are taxed for a Singapore or UAE resident. An individual may owe India no capital gains tax at all. Both treaties let India tax gains on shares of Indian companies but leave gains on "any other property" to the investor's country of residence. This article also explains how each treaty reaches that result - how mutual funds are not shares, the leading decisions as per various tribunals, how India's other treaties compare and what an investor must do.Position in Indian LawWithout a treaty, India taxes a non-resident's mutual fund gains in full, and the tax is withheld on redemption. From 1 April 2026, the law is the Income-tax Act, 2025, as amended by the Finance Act, 2026. The rates as per the Income Tax Department (surcharge and 4% cess extra) are as follows:Category of fundShort-term gainLong-term gainEquity-orientated fund (long-term if held over 12 months)20% - section 196 (old s.111A)12.5% above ₹1.25 lakh - section 198 (old s.112A)Specified mutual fund (65% or more in debt-oriented mutual fund and money-market instruments, on an annual average of daily closing figures)Deemed short-term for units purchased on or after 1 April 2023, slab rates - section 76(1) (old s.50AA)Not availableOther fundsSlab rates12.5%, no indexation - section 197 (old s.112)Income from units (IDCW)20% on units bought in foreign currency - section 207; withholding at 20% or the lower treaty rate - section 393(2), Table Sl. No. 10 and Note 2, read with sections 2 and 402 (old s.196A)—Points to remember:The deemed short-term capital gain on debt funds is still "capital gains", so the DTAA's article on Capital Gain governs it.Treaty relief is as per section 159 in the Income Tax Act 2025, which replaced sections 90 and 90A (Income Tax Act 1961); a non-resident may still apply the treaty where it is more beneficial.The Core: "shares" versus "any other property"Article 13 (Capital Gains) of both DTAAs allocates taxing rights as follows:Immovable property and permanent-establishment assets: taxable where the property or PE is. Not relevant to a portfolio investor.Shares of an Indian company: India may tax the same.Any other property (Article 13(5) in both treaties): taxable only in the seller's country of residence.Indian mutual funds are trusts under the SEBI (Mutual Funds) Regulations and not companies. The investor holds a unit of a trust, not a share, so the unit falls through to Article 13(5).Legal Interpretation:Article 3(2): Neither treaty defines "shares", so the term takes its Indian law meaning unless the context requires otherwise.Section 2(84) of the Companies Act, 2013, defines a share as a share in the share capital of a company; a mutual fund has no share capital.Section 2(h) of the Securities Contracts (Regulation) Act, 1956, lists shares and units in separate sub-clauses.There are no notifications under old section 90(3) as per the Income Tax Act 1961 that have equated the two viz. shares and mutual funds.The Income Tax Department cannot include units in the share paragraph.India-Singapore DTAAGains on Indian fund units by a Singapore resident are taxable only in Singapore under Article 13(5), whenever the units were bought.Residence (Article 4). A Singapore resident is a person liable to tax there by reason of domicile, residence or similar criterion. For dual residents, the tiebreaker looks in turn at permanent home, centre of vital interests, habitual abode and nationality, so an NRI who keeps a family home in India must show his centre of vital interests has moved from India to Singapore.Structure of Article 13.13(1) immovable properties: where situated;13(2) PE or fixed-base assets: where the PE is;13(3) ships and aircraft: operator's residence state only;13(4A) - (4C) shares, added by the 2016 Protocol;13(5) everything else: residence state only.Evolution: Until 2017, gains on Indian shares were taxable only in Singapore, making Singapore, along with Mauritius, a favoured source for investment in India. A 2005 protocol made that exemption conditional on the Mauritius treaty continuing to exempt share gains and added a limitation of benefits test. When India amended the Mauritius treaty in May 2016, it amended the Singapore treaty that December, effective 1 April 2017.The synthesised text now reads:13(4A): "Gains from the alienation of shares acquired before 1 April 2017 in a company which is a resident of a Contracting State shall be taxable only in the Contracting State in which the alienator is a resident."13(4B): "Gains from the alienation of shares acquired on or after 1 April 2017 in a company which is a resident of a Contracting State may be taxed in that State."13(4C): gains under 13(4B) between 1 April 2017 and 31 March 2019 were taxable at no more than 50% of the domestic rate.The Limitation of Benefits clause in Article 24A covers only the following:An arrangement made mainly to obtain the share-gain benefit loses it;A shell or conduit company loses it.A company is presumed to be a shell or conduit if its annual operating spend is below S$200,000 in Singapore or ₹50 lakh in India, measured over the 24 months before the gain under 13(4A) or the 12 months under 13(4C);A listed company, or one that meets the spending test, is presumed not to be one.Hence, from above, we can infer that Limitation of Benefits Clause in India-Singapore DTAA cover only article 13(4A) and 13(4C) and doesn't cover Article 13(5) in which units, bonds and debentures are covered.Hence, reference or interpretation must be strictly done as per Article 13(5):"Gains from the alienation of any property other than that referred to in paragraphs 1, 2, 3, 4A and 4B of this Article shall be taxable only in the Contracting State of which the alienator is a resident."The Mumbai Tribunal confirmed this in Anushka Sanjay Shah v. ITO (26 March 2025, AY 2022-23) for equity and debt units bought from 1st April 2017.The Capital Gain on the sale of units must be taxed for Singapore residents in Singapore only, and since no capital gains are taxed in Singapore, and Singapore's resident individuals are generally exempt from foreign-sourced income, the individual pays no tax anywhere.From above, we can infer that the Capital Gain on the sale of units must be taxed for Singapore residents in Singapore only, and since no capital gains are taxed in Singapore, and Singapore's resident individuals are generally exempt from foreign-sourced income, the individual pays no tax anywhere.Different rules may apply to a business that trades in units. Singapore companies should also consider section 10L of Singapore's Income Tax Act, which, since 1 January 2024, taxes foreign-asset gains received in Singapore by group entities that lack sufficient economic substance there.India-UAE DTAACapital gains on Indian fund units by a UAE resident are taxable in the UAE under Article 13(5), but the UAE levies no personal income tax. Hence, making it exempt in both countries.Structure of Article 13. The pattern matches Singapore's, without a date-wise split for shares:13(1) immovable property: where situated;13(2) PE or fixed-base assets: where the PE is;13(3) shares of a company whose property consists principally of immovable property may be taxed where the property is situated;13(4) shares of a company resident in a Contracting State: may be taxed in that State;13(5) any other property: residence state only.The treaty (signed on 29th April 1992, in force from 22nd September 1993, amended in 2007 and 2013) never exempted capital gains on shares, so there was no grandfathering. But under the published treaty text, Article 13(4) speaks only of shares, and Article 13(5) makes other gains "taxable only in the Contracting State of which the alienator is a resident".In DCIT v. K.E. Faizal (ITA 423/Coch/2018, AY 2012-13, 8 July 2019), the Assessing Officer argued that equity mutual fund units are shares in nature because domestic law taxes them the same. The Cochin Tribunal disagreed and held that the Companies Act defines shares and mutual funds as not included in them. It also held that SEBI requires mutual funds to be trusts, and securities law treats shares and mutual funds as two different instruments.Residence (Article 4): With no personal income tax, UAE individuals long risked failing the "liable to tax" test. The 2007 Protocol defines an individual as UAE resident if one is "present in the UAE for a period or periods totalling in the aggregate at least 183 days in the calendar year concerned". Without a TRC, the claim fails. It can also be noted that UAE corporate tax (9% since June 2023) matters only for units held through a UAE company and not the individual.The 2007 Protocol defines an individual as UAE resident if one is "present in the UAE for a period or periods totalling in the aggregate at least 183 days in the calendar year concerned".Check the UAE TRC. Since 1 March 2023, UAE law (Cabinet Decision No. 85 of 2022) treats an individual as a resident on any of three tests:Primary residence and centre of interests in the UAE;183 days in a period of 12 months; or90 days in a period of 12 months for UAE or GCC nationals or permit holders with a permanent home, job or business there.The treaty test is narrower: 183 days in the calendar year.A TRC issued based on the 90-day condition or a 12-month period other than a calendar year may not satisfy the DTAA's residency test, so check accordingly and keep a record of entry and exit in the passport.What do Tribunals Say?The leading rulings in this matter hold that units are not shares under a DTAA's capital gains article, as mentioned in the table below.RulingForum and yearDTAAHoldingAnushka Sanjay Shah v. ITOITAT Mumbai, dt. 26 March 2025 (AY 2022-23)India-SingaporeEquity and debt units bought after 1 April 2017 fall under Art. 13(5) and not 13(4B)Emerging India Focus Funds v. ACITITAT Delhi, 2025India-MauritiusEquity-oriented units are not "shares" under Art. 13(3A); the residuary clause appliesDCIT v. K.E. FaizalITAT Cochin, dt. 8 July 2019 (AY 2012-13), 178 ITD 383India-UAEEquity-oriented units fall under Art. 13(5)ITO v. Satish Beharilal RahejaITAT Mumbai, 2013 (AY 2004-05), 37 taxmann.com 296India-SwitzerlandUnits are not shares; a residuary clause appliesThe common citation is of Apollo Tyres v. CIT (SC, 2002), read with CIT v. Mother India Refrigeration Industries (1985) 155 ITR 711 (SC): a deeming fiction reaches only as far as it says.From above it can be inferred that "Taxing equity-fund units like listed shares does not make them "shares" in a treaty".In my view, the same reasoning should be extended to ETFs and index funds, which are mutual fund schemes even though their units are traded on an exchange; no ruling has addressed them yet.These are only Tribunal rulings, and at the moment, neither the High Court nor the Supreme Court has yet settled the matter, so there is a possibility that the Income Tax Department will still litigate and go on an appeal for the same.Income Distribution cum Capital Withdrawal (IDCW) payouts are a different storyThe residence-only result covers gains on redemption, not distributions.Under section 393(2) (Table Sl. No. 10), read with sections 2 and 402, the fund deducts 20% on income from units paid to a non-resident;Note 2 lowers this to a lower DTAA rate where the payee furnishes a Tax Residency Certificate. Section 207 fixes 20% on units bought in foreign currency. These replace old sections 196A and 115A.Article 10(4) of the Singapore DTAA defines dividends by reference to distributions by a "company", and the UAE definition is similar. A mutual fund is a trust, so its payouts are unlikely to be "dividends" and can be considered as follows:Singapore: Article 23 (Income Not Expressly Mentioned) says such items "may be taxed in accordance with the taxation laws of the respective Contracting States", so the rate is 20% in India.UAE: Article 22 (Other Income) gives income not dealt with elsewhere to the residence country, which supports a claim that IDCW is not taxable in India.Investors seeking DTAA protection therefore usually prefer growth options.Practical ChecklistThe benefits can be claimed on the basis of the investor's residence and paperwork.Tax Residency Certificate: Section 159(8) allows relief "only when the non-resident obtains a certificate of residence from the Government of that country" and provides prescribed information. UAE residents should be careful that it is as per the DTAA.Form 41 and fund records: File Form 41 (formerly Form 10F) every financial year. Before redeeming, please ensure that the overseas address and status are with the registrar and issue the TRC and Form 41 to the registrar.Withholding and refunds: Registrars often withhold at domestic rates. For a large redemption, a nil or lower deduction certificate under section 395(1)(a) (old s.197) may be applied as per Form No. 128, which can avoid a months-long refund cycle. Otherwise, a relief can be claimed in the Income Tax Return, citing Article 13(5) in the DTAA schedule.Residence and timing: Under section 6(7), an Indian citizen with Indian income above ₹15 lakh who is not liable to tax elsewhere is deemed to be a resident in India, a real risk for UAE residents. Track the number of days stayed in India for the tax year and abroad for the treaty test. Before redemption, determine Indian residential status for the entire tax year and treaty residence for the relevant period. Redemption before physical return does not, by itself, ensure treaty relief.Anti-abuse rules and substance: Article 7 of the Multilateral Instrument (MLI), as applied to the Singapore or UAE treaty, denies a benefit if obtaining it was one of the principal purposes of an arrangement or transaction; India's GAAR may do the same. Singapore's Limitation of Benefits clause does not apply to Article 13(5). In AAR v. Tiger Global International II Holdings (SC, 15 January 2026), the Supreme Court held that a TRC is necessary but not conclusive evidence of treaty entitlement. Accordingly, CBDT Circular No. 789 dated 13-4-2000, which treated a Mauritian TRC as sufficient evidence of residence, must now be read subject to the provisions of GAAR. This may have little effect on an NRI living abroad genuinely, but companies or family offices/vehicles must demonstrate genuine management in their country of residence.Litigation risk: Expect scrutiny of large claims until a High Court or Supreme Court passes the Judgement in this matter. Until then, please keep the TRC, Form 41, fund statements and the Tribunal rulings on file.The two treaties side by sidePointIndia-SingaporeIndia-UAETreaty and key amendment(s)1994; Protocol of 2016 (effective 1 April 2017)1992 (in force 1993); Protocols of 2007 and 2013Gains on shares of Indian companiesTaxable in India if acquired on or after 1 April 2017 (13(4B)); earlier residence only (13(4A))Taxable in India (13(4))Gains on mutual fund unitsResidence only (13(5))Residence only (13(5))Leading rulingAnushka Sanjay Shah (2025)K.E. Faizal (2019)Income from units (IDCW)India may tax (Art. 23)Arguably residence only (Art. 22)Tax at home for individualsNo capital gains taxNo personal income taxIndividual residence testSingapore tax residence, shown by TRC183 days in the calendar year (Art. 4), shown by TRCAnti-abuse clauseLimitation of Benefits (Art. 24A), limited to 13(4A) and 13(4C); Multilateral Instrument Principal Purpose Test (MLI PPT) appliesArticle 29 (entities only); MLI PPTBeyond Singapore and the UAE: How India's other treaties compareIndia's treaties fall into two camps on fund gains, depending on how the capital gains article is drafted.Camp one: a residuary clause sends "other property" gains to be taxed in the residence country only: OECD and UN-model treaties list what India may tax, and units are in the residuary catch-all clause. The Mumbai Tribunal had applied this to the Swiss DTAA in Raheja (2013), six years before the Kochi Tribunal to the UAE DTAA in Faizal (2019), the Delhi Tribunal to the Mauritius DTAA in Emerging India Focus Funds (2025) and again the Mumbai Tribunal to the Singapore Treaty post the 2016 change in Anushka Sanjay Shah (2025). India's treaties with Mauritius, the Netherlands, Germany, France, Ireland, Switzerland, Saudi Arabia, Kuwait, Qatar and Oman also belong to this camp.Camp two: each country taxes under its own law. India's treaties with the United States (Article 13), United Kingdom (Article 14) and Canada (Article 13) do not divide taxing rights on capital gains. India–Australia reaches the same result by a different route: Article 13(6) says,"Nothing in this Agreement affects the application of a law of a Contracting State relating to the taxation of gains of a capital nature derived from the alienation of property other than that to which any of paragraphs (1), (2), (3), (4) and (5) apply."Indian Mutual Fund units fall within this. Each country keeps its domestic right, with only a foreign tax credit that can be claimed in the country of residence, so India's 12.5% or 20% applies in full.Residence countryTreaty route for unit gainsTaxable in India?Tax at homeSingaporeResiduary Article 13(5)NoGenerally – none for individualsUAEResiduary Article 13(5)NoNone for individualsSaudi Arabia, Kuwait, Qatar, OmanResiduary clauseNoGenerally – none for individualsMauritiusResiduary clause (Emerging India Focus Funds, 2025); 2016 Protocol taxes only sharesNoNo capital gains taxSwitzerlandResiduary clause (Raheja)NoPrivate gains generally exemptGermany, France, Ireland, NetherlandsResiduary clauseNoYes, under the domestic laws.United States, United Kingdom, Canada, AustraliaDomestic law clauseYesYes, with credit for Indian taxWe can infer:Shifting the taxing right is not a tax-saving method: A German resident escapes Indian tax but pays about 26.4% in Germany; a French resident pays French tax on capital gains. Zero tax needs both a residuary clause and a home country that does not tax the gain, like Singapore, the UAE, other Gulf states and Mauritius.The 2016 Protocols were narrow. India's renegotiations with Mauritius, Cyprus and Singapore targeted only round-tripped investment in shares and added nothing on units, bonds or derivatives.US residents have an additional check: Indian funds are usually PFICs for US persons, taxed punitively in the US over and above the Indian tax, the opposite of the Singapore and UAE positions.Indian funds are usually PFICs for US persons, taxed punitively in the US over and above the Indian tax, the opposite of the Singapore and UAE positions.For other countries, investors should read their own treaty: understand the carve-out on securities or substantial holdings and check whether there have been amendments by Protocol or the OECD-MLI.An ExampleThree NRIs each redeem equity-orientated fund units held for ten months as a short-term capital gain of ₹10 lakh, with no other Indian income:InvestorWithheld at redemptionFinal Indian taxTax at homeUAE resident (UAE TRC)₹2.08 lakhs (20% under s.196 + 4% cess)Nil; refunded on filing with TRC and Form 41NilSingapore resident (Singapore TRC)₹2.08 lakhsNil; refunded on filingGenerally nilUS resident₹2.08 lakhs₹2.08 lakhsUS tax less foreign tax credit (PFIC rules apply)The UAE and Singapore investors end up paying no tax, but sometimes the Department may raise queries on the same before refund. The US investor gets no treaty relief.Note: Figures ignore surcharge (above ₹50 lakhs income) and assume no deemed Indian residence.ConclusionUnder both treaties, gains on Indian fund units belong to the country of residence, and neither Singapore nor the UAE taxes the capital gains in the individual's hands.US, UK, Australian and Canadian residents pay full Indian tax, whereas German or French or Dutch or Irish residents pay at home.The position is as per the DTAA and leading Tribunal rulings. Until there are any changes, investors who are genuine residents abroad, with a valid TRC and filed Indian Income Tax Returns, can claim the exemption with reasonable confidence.What to watch: any department appeal against Anushka Sanjay Shah in the Bombay High Court; any renegotiation of Article 13 to add units or other such similar items; and the department's approach to DTAA claims post Tiger Global.Kindly verify the legal position before every large redemption.Note: This article is general information, not legal or tax advice. Figures and treaty positions are as of 30 September 2026.ReferencesIncome Tax Department, Government of India (incometaxindia.gov.in)India-Singapore DTAA: synthesised text with MLIIndia-UAE DTAA: comprehensive agreementIncome-tax Act, 2025, as amended by the Finance Act, 2026Section 76 (specified mutual funds; old s.50AA)Section 159 (treaty relief)Section 196 (short-term capital gains)Section 197 (long-term capital gains; old s.112)Section 198 (long-term capital gains in certain cases; old s.112A)Section 207 (20% on income from units bought in foreign currency, Table Sl. No. 7)Section 393 (tax deducted at source; old ss.195 and 196A)Section 395 (lower or nil deduction certificate; old s.197)Tax on short-term capital gains and tax on long-term capital gainsForm 41 and Form No. 128CBDT Circular No. 789 dated 13-4-2000Anushka Sanjay Shah v. ITO, ITA 174/Mum/2025DCIT v. K.E. Faizal, ITA 423/Coch/2018ITO v. Satish Beharilal Raheja, ITA 4627/Mum/2009Emerging India Focus Funds v. ACIT, ITA 1963/Del/2025AAR (Income Tax) v. Tiger Global International II Holdings, Supreme Court of IndiaCIT v. Mother India Refrigeration Industries (P) Ltd, (1985) 155 ITR 711 (SC)Apollo Tyres v. CIT, (2002) 255 ITR 273 (SC)UAE Cabinet Decision No. 85 of 2022 on tax residency (effective 1 March 2023)Singapore Income Tax Act, section 10L (from 1 January 2024)Author can be reached atsashank.srivatsan24@gmail.com and eboard@icai.inThe Chartered Accountant | November 2026 | www.icai.org | pp. 29–34
Ep. 554 — International Tax and MLI PPT in Practice: Treaty Entitlement, GAAR Interplay, and Substance Expectations
CA Journal
00:00--:--
International Tax and MLI PPT in Practice: Treaty Entitlement, GAAR Interplay, and Substance ExpectationsTreaty entitlement in India has moved from a form-led TRC analysis to a substance-driven anti-abuse enquiry. A valid TRC and prescribed information remain essential, but they do not conclusively establish treaty access where the Revenue alleges treaty shopping, conduit features or lack of commercial rationale. The MLI Principal Purpose Test, domestic GAAR and recent jurisprudence, particularly Tiger Global1, require taxpayers to demonstrate genuine residence, decision-making, risk control, commercial substance and non-tax reasons for the structure. Treaty claims should therefore be supported by contemporaneous documentation, robust governance records and a clear evidentiary narrative showing that the benefit is consistent with the treaty's object and purpose.IntroductionCross-border tax planning in India is increasingly assessed through an integrated anti-abuse lens. Treaty entitlement is no longer based only on residence certificates, legal ownership or literal treaty wording. The modern enquiry examines whether the claimant has genuine treaty residence, whether it is the beneficial owner where the relevant article so requires, whether the arrangement has commercial substance, and whether obtaining the treaty benefit was a principal or main purpose of the structure.This shift is driven by the Multilateral Instrument ("MLI"), the Principal Purpose Test ("PPT"), India's domestic General Anti-Avoidance Rules ("GAAR"), and recent judicial developments. The Income-tax Act, 2025 ("2025 Act") and Income-tax Rules, 2026 ("2026 Rules"), retain the core treaty documentation framework, including the Tax Residency Certificate ("TRC") and Form No. 41. However, recent case law has made it clear that documentation is only the starting point. A defensible treaty claim must also be supported by evidence of governance, decision-making, risk assumption and non-tax commercial rationale.Treaty Entitlement: The Foundation of International TaxationTreaty entitlement begins with demonstration of residence in the other contracting state under the relevant tax treaty. For an Indian treaty claim, a non-resident must produce a TRC issued by the foreign jurisdiction and furnish prescribed information under section 159(8) of the 2025 Act read with Rule 75 of the 2026 Rules and Form No. 41. Rule 75(2) also requires maintenance of supporting records for verification by the income-tax authority.The TRC remains a statutory necessity and carries significant evidentiary value. It establishes prima facie residence and continues to be relevant for administrative certainty. However, it is no longer safe to treat the TRC as conclusive in all circumstances. Where the facts suggest a conduit entity, treaty shopping, externally dictated decision-making or absence of meaningful commercial activity, the Revenue may examine the wider arrangement and deny treaty benefit if the legal conditions for anti-abuse action are met.Beneficial ownership and substance are related but distinct concepts. Beneficial ownership is generally relevant to specific treaty articles, particularly dividends, interest and royalties. Substance is broader. It asks whether the entity performs real functions, assumes and controls risks, deploys capital, maintains independent governance and has a commercial reason to exist in the chosen jurisdiction. A structure supported only by formal incorporation, outsourced compliance and routine board approvals is likely to face greater scrutiny.The MLI and the PPT: A New Era of Tax Treaty Anti-AbuseThe MLI was introduced under the BEPS project to modify bilateral tax treaties without renegotiating each treaty separately. Its key anti-abuse objective is reflected in Article 6, which modifies treaty preambles to clarify that treaties are intended to eliminate double taxation without creating opportunities for non-taxation or reduced taxation through evasion, avoidance or treaty shopping.Article 7 contains the PPT. It permits denial of a treaty benefit where, having regard to all relevant facts and circumstances, it is reasonable to conclude that obtaining that benefit was one of the principal purposes of an arrangement or transaction, unless granting the benefit would be in accordance with the object and purpose of the relevant treaty provision. The benefit need not be the sole or dominant purpose; being one of the principal purposes may be sufficient.Cross-border tax planning in India is increasingly assessed through an integrated anti-abuse lens. Treaty entitlement is no longer based only on residence certificates, legal ownership or literal treaty wording.The PPT is objective and fact-intensive. Relevant indicators include the timing of steps, design of the legal structure, economic effect, availability of alternative routes, actual decision-making, business rationale for the jurisdiction, personnel and premises, duration of operations and whether the claimant performs a meaningful commercial role. Tax efficiency alone should not be fatal; the concern arises where the tax benefit appears to be a principal driver, and the structure lacks independent commercial substance.GAAR in India: Domestic Anti-Avoidance RuleIndia's GAAR is contained in Chapter XI of the 2025 Act. Section 178 permits an arrangement to be declared an impermissible avoidance arrangement, while section 179 identifies the core trigger: a main purpose of obtaining a tax benefit, together with at least one tainted element. These tainted elements include non-arm's-length rights or obligations, misuse or abuse of the 2025 Act, lack of commercial substance, or an arrangement entered or carried out in a manner not ordinarily employed for bona fide purposes.GAAR consequences may be wider than treaty denial. They can include recharacterisation, disregard or combination of steps, look-through, reallocation of income or expenses, and denial of treaty benefit. Rule 128 of the 2026 Rules prescribes exceptions, including the Rs. 3 crore aggregate tax-benefit threshold, specified FII-related exclusions and grandfathering for income from the transfer of investments made before 1 April 2017.PPT and GAAR overlap but are not identical. PPT is treaty-based and focuses on whether treaty access itself was one of the principal purposes of the arrangement. GAAR is domestic law, applies a main-purpose threshold, requires tainted elements and may produce broader consequences. In practice, the Revenue may analyse the same facts through treaty LOB provisions, beneficial ownership, PPT-type reasoning, GAAR and judicial anti-avoidance principles, subject to the procedural safeguards applicable to each route.CBDT Notification Nos. 54/2026 and 55/2026 clarify that GAAR will not apply to income from transfer of investments made before 1 April 2017, irrespective of when the arrangement was entered into and even if the tax benefit is realised on or after that date. This clarification is significant for legacy investments, though disputes may continue where the Revenue alleges that the benefit arises from a broader post-cut-off restructuring or arrangement rather than from the transfer of a grandfathered investment itself.Substance Expectations: The New NormalSubstance is now the practical centre of treaty defence. The enquiry is no longer satisfied by showing that an entity was legally incorporated and held a TRC. Taxpayers should be able to explain why the entity exists, why the chosen jurisdiction was commercially relevant, what functions the entity performed, who made key decisions, where risk was controlled and how capital was deployed.Useful evidence would include board minutes reflecting real deliberation, investment memoranda, delegation matrices, banking mandates, financial statements, local expenditure, employee or director capability, risk-monitoring records and contemporaneous papers recording commercial drivers. Substance is not a single numeric threshold; it is a cumulative evidentiary narrative showing that the entity had a genuine role beyond obtaining a tax outcome.Indian Case Law: Judicial Approach to Treaty Entitlement, GAAR, and SubstanceIndian case law reflects an evolution from strong respect for legal form to a more substance-orientated approach. In Azadi Bachao Andolan2, the Supreme Court upheld the significance of a TRC and recognised that treaty shopping was not per se illegal unless the arrangement was abusive. In Vodafone3, the Court emphasised corporate separateness and the taxpayer's right to arrange affairs within the law, while also recognising that sham or colourable arrangements may be disregarded.Those decisions remain important, but they must now be read in the context of GAAR, treaty anti-abuse provisions, beneficial ownership requirements and the MLI framework. A TRC still has evidentiary value, but it does not automatically prevent scrutiny where the facts indicate that the claimant may be a conduit or that the arrangement lacks commercial substance.Tiger Global is now central to this debate. The Delhi High Court in Tiger Global4 had adopted a taxpayer-favourable approach by giving significant weight to the TRC, treaty grandfathering and the absence of clear evidence of sham. The Supreme Court's 2026 ruling5 reversed that approach and restored the AAR's rejection of the applications at the threshold. The Court accepted that authorities may examine whether a transaction is prima facie designed for tax avoidance and whether treaty benefit should be denied despite formal documentation.Relevant indicators include the timing of steps, design of the legal structure, economic effect, availability of alternative routes, actual decision-making, business rationale for the jurisdiction, personnel and premises, duration of operations and whether the claimant performs a meaningful commercial role.The key takeaways from Tiger Global are that a TRC is necessary but not conclusive; the Revenue may examine control, management, bank-operation protocols and investment-manager dominance; the distinction between an "investment" and a wider "arrangement" may be relevant; and treaty entitlement must be tested against commercial substance and non-tax business rationale. The ruling materially strengthens the Revenue's ability to challenge interposed holding structures where the factual record is weak.Practical Application: PPT and GAAR in Indian Tax AdministrationCBDT Circular No. 01/20256 clarifies that the PPT applies prospectively from the date of entry into effect of the MLI for the relevant treaty, that treaty-specific grandfathering provisions such as those in the India-Mauritius and India-Singapore treaties are not affected by the PPT, and that PPT application is a fact-based exercise. It also permits reference to the OECD Commentary and the UN Model Tax Convention as supplementary guidance.Key Considerations for TaxpayersTaxpayers should approach treaty claims as if they were building a litigation file from the outset. The following areas are particularly important:Substance: Demonstrate real economic activity, decision-making authority, governance and operational presence in the residence jurisdiction.Commercial rationale: Document the non-tax business reasons for the structure, including commercial, regulatory, financing or operational considerations.Documentation: Maintain robust supporting records, including the TRC, Form No. 41, board minutes, investment memoranda, delegation matrices, banking mandates, financial statements, local expenditure records and evidence of independent management.Review of existing structures: Reassess existing holding and investment structures, particularly legacy structures, exit planning, internal reorganisations close to monetisation events and post-2017 steps affecting pre-2017 investments, considering the PPT and GAAR framework.Existing structures should be reassessed, particularly where treaty benefit depends on legacy investments, holding entities with limited activity, exits after internal reorganisation, or post-2017 steps affecting pre-2017 investments. The taxpayer should separately test each basis for treaty access - residence, LOB compliance, grandfathering, beneficial ownership and business purpose - rather than relying on a single document or proposition.Applicability of the MLI: Impact of the Supreme Court's Decision in the Case of Nestle7 and the Subsequent JurisprudenceThe MLI operates as an overlay to existing bilateral treaties. It applies only where both treaty partners have listed the treaty as a Covered Tax Agreement and have adopted the relevant MLI provisions without reservations that prevent matching. India ratified the MLI and issued a notification8 under section 90(1) of the 1961 Act giving effect to India's MLI position.The Supreme Court's decision in Nestle (supra), though dealing with MFN clauses, has influenced the debate on whether MLI modifications require treaty-specific domestic notification. The Court held that, in India's dualist system, treaty provisions affecting domestic rights and obligations require notification under section 90(1) of the 1961 Act before they can be enforced.Tribunal rulings such as Sky High Appeal XLIII Leasing9 and Kosi Aviation Leasing10 have applied this reasoning to the MLI and taken the view that Articles 6 and 7 cannot be enforced for a treaty unless the relevant modification is specifically notified. CBDT Circular No. 1/2025 proceeds on the contrary premise that India's general MLI notification is sufficient for Covered Tax Agreements. Until appellate clarity emerges, treaty-specific MLI enforceability should be verified carefully.Conclusion: The Road AheadThe combined effect of the MLI, PPT, GAAR and recent case law is that treaty claims must now be prepared, not merely asserted. A valid TRC and prescribed information remain essential, but they are only the foundation. The claimant must also demonstrate that the structure has commercial substance, real governance, business rationale and consistency with the object and purpose of the relevant treaty provision.Azadi Bachao Andolan11 and Vodafone12 continue to protect genuine legal form and legitimate tax planning. Tiger Global13, however, confirms that those principles do not insulate arrangements lacking substance or commercial purpose. The Revenue can look beyond formal documentation where the facts suggest conduit features, externally controlled decision-making or an impermissible avoidance arrangement.Going forward, taxpayers should maintain contemporaneous evidence of substance, governance and non-tax commercial rationale. Legacy structures and proposed transactions should be stress-tested under treaty conditions, PPT, GAAR, SAARs and beneficial ownership principles. The practical standard is clear: treaty benefits are more defensible when the structure is commercially credible, operationally real and capable of withstanding a cumulative anti-abuse review.The practical standard is clear: treaty benefits are more defensible when the structure is commercially credible, operationally real and capable of withstanding a cumulative anti-abuse review.◆◆◆Author may be reached at agrawalaakash51@gmail.com and eboard@icai.inHon'ble Supreme Court in AAR vs. Tiger Global International II Holdings [2026] 485 ITR 214 (SC)Hon'ble Supreme Court in Union of India vs. Azadi Bachao Andolan [2003] 263 ITR 706 (SC)Hon'ble Supreme Court in Vodafone International Holdings BV v. Union of India [2012] 341 ITR 1 (SC)Hon'ble Delhi High Court in Tiger Global International III Holdings vs. AAR [2024] 468 ITR 405 (Delhi)Hon'ble Supreme Court in AAR vs. Tiger Global International II Holdings [2026] 485 ITR 214 (SC)Circular No. 01/2025 dated 21 January 2025Hon'ble Supreme Court in Assessing Officer (International Taxation) vs. Nestle SA [2023] 458 ITR 756 (SC) – The Review Petition [[2024] 165 taxmann.com 334 (SC)] as well as the Curative Petition [[2025] 178 taxmann.com 728 (SC)] against the said decision has also been dismissed by the Hon'ble Supreme CourtNotification No. 57/2019 dated 9 August 2019Hon'ble Mumbai Tribunal in Sky High Appeal XLIII Leasing Company Ltd. v. ACIT [2025] 177 taxmann.com 579 (Mumbai - Trib.)Hon'ble Delhi Tribunal in Kosi Aviation Leasing Ltd vs. ACIT [2025] 179 taxmann.com 166 (Delhi – Trib.)Hon'ble Supreme Court in Union of India vs. Azadi Bachao Andolan [2003] 263 ITR 706 (SC)Hon'ble Supreme Court in Vodafone International Holdings BV v. Union of India [2012] 341 ITR 1 (SC)Hon'ble Supreme Court in AAR vs. Tiger Global International II Holdings [2026] 485 ITR 214 (SC)The Chartered Accountant | November 2026 | pp. 35–38 | www.icai.org